Law & Courts

Justices Weigh Colleges’ Right to Limit Military Recruiters

By Andrew Trotter — December 13, 2005 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The U.S. Supreme Court appears inclined to uphold a law that denies federal funding to colleges that do not give military recruiters the same campus access to students that other potential employers get. The justices’ thinking emerged during oral arguments last week in a challenge to the law brought by a group of law schools.

The fate of the law, called the Solomon Amendment, which Congress first passed in 1994 and has expanded several times since, has implications for a provision in the federal No Child Left Behind Act.

The NCLB provision, in addition to requiring that school districts that receive federal money give military recruiters student directory information, also requires that districts “provide military recruiters the same access to secondary school students as is provided generally to postsecondary educational institutions or to prospective employers of those students.”

The case was brought by the Forum for Academic and Institutional Rights Inc., or FAIR, an association of law professors and 38 law schools that oppose the military’s policy of excluding openly gay employees. The law schools are members of the Association of American Law Schools, which requires that its members not discriminate against gay and lesbian students, and also that they admit to on-campus job fairs only those employers that pledge not to discriminate against individuals on the basis of sexual orientation.

Under the “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy enacted by Congress in 1993, the armed forces do not allow openly gay people to serve.

Congress, by using its purse strings to force campuses to let military recruiters in, is interfering with the law schools’ First Amendment rights of free speech and association, argued E. Joshua Rosenkranz, a New York City lawyer representing the schools in the Dec. 6 arguments in Rumsfeld v. FAIR (Case No. 04-1152).

In court papers, the law schools cited the Supreme Court’s 2000 decision in Boy Scouts of America v. Dale, which supported the Boy Scouts’ firing of an openly gay scoutmaster because, the Scouts said, the presence of members who are gay would burden the organization’s message. The law schools argued that their message against employment discrimination is similarly burdened by the presence of military recruiters.

But the Bush administration argued that the recruiters do not pose such a burden because they are not asking to be members in the law schools’ group.

Symbolic Speech?

Solicitor General Paul D. Clement, representing the government, said the Solomon Amendment “allows the military a fair shot to recruit the best and brightest” from the nation’s law schools. He said the law schools “remain free to criticize the military and its policies.” Alternatively, he said, they are “free to refuse federal funds” if they don’t wish to have the recruiters on campus.

Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. picked up on that theme, saying that Congress was telling federally funded higher education institutions, “If you want our money, you have to accept our conditions.”

Mr. Rosenkranz’s suggestion that students would not believe a law school’s anti-discrimination policy if military recruiters were participating in the school’s job fairs prompted a quick retort from Chief Justice Roberts.

“The reason they don’t believe you is your willingness to take the [federal] money,” said the chief justice, provoking soft laughter in the courtroom.

Justice David H. Souter seemed sympathetic to the law schools’ position that “the university, by creating the forum for recruiting, [is] speaking.” He characterized the military’s message as “Join the army, but not if you’re gay.”

But several justices were skeptical of Mr. Rosenkranz’s argument that a law school job fair amounted to speech by the school.

Justice Anthony M. Kennedy suggested that the law schools could add disclaimers to e-mails and other literature advertising the job fairs that said they disagreed with the military’s policy.

Justice Stephen G. Breyer took issue with the law schools’ attempt to keep the military out. “The remedy for speech you don’t like is not less speech, it’s more speech,” he said.

The K-12 Context

Thomas Hutton, a lawyer with the National School Boards Association, said he expects the high court to uphold the Solomon Amendment out of deference to Congress and the military. If the court did strike it down, he said it was unclear whether the similar provision in the No Child Left Behind Act would be affected.

“Higher education is a little different from public K-12 schools,” he said. “I’m not sure what particular basis the court would use [to strike down the K-12 requirement]; whether you could import associational expression to the K-12 context, I’m not sure.”

He said the clearer impact of the case “is a political one, that it’s focusing attention on the military recruiters issue” in high schools and how districts administer their responsibilities to give the military access to students and deal with protesters against that access.

A decision in the case is expected by July.

Related Tags:

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
College & Workforce Readiness Webinar
From Student Trends to Counselor Action: Turning Insight Into Impact
Find out what is changing in how students approach planning for life after graduation and how schools can help.
Content provided by PowerSchool
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
McKinney-Vento Transportation Strategies: Managing Cost & Protecting Access
Explore McKinney-Vento transportation strategies to manage costs, respond quickly to changing needs, and protect student access.
Content provided by HopSkipDrive
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Families & the Community Webinar
Celebrate Family Engagement Day With Strategies That Work
Join National PTA and AASA to explore practical systems-wide family engagement strategies in celebration of National Family Engagement Day.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Law & Courts Washington State Sued Over Newly Approved Trans Student-Athlete Ban
The lawsuit says school sports are an essential part of education, including for transgender students.
Daniel Beekman, The Seattle Times
•
2 min read
The Washington State Capitol in Olympia, Wash. on Nov. 10, 2026.
The Washington State Capitol in Olympia, Wash. on Nov. 10, 2026. Opponents of a ballot initiative that passed last week that will ban transgender girls from girls' school athletic teams have sued the state, alleging the measure violates state law and Washington's state constitution.
Jay Beiler/Dreamstime via TNS
Law & Courts Can This Religious Preschool Exclude LGBTQ Families and Still Get State Funding?
The Supreme Court appears ready to let Catholic preschools bypass Colorado’s LGBTQ+ anti-discrimination requirement.
5 min read
The Supreme Court is seen at day's end in Washington, Thursday, Oct. 1, 2026, as the justices prepare to begin the new term next week.
The U.S. Supreme Court, seen here in Washington on Oct. 1, 2026, appeared ready to side with Catholic preschools in challenging Colorado’s requirement that publicly funded providers sign an anti-discrimination pledge covering sexual orientation and gender identity.
J. Scott Applewhite/AP
Law & Courts Can Public Schools Try to Boost Diversity? Admissions Policies Face a New Test
Challenges to race-neutral methods for selective admissions are continuing.
6 min read
Photo collage of the Supreme Court building with a diverse group of teens superimposed over it.
Collage by Gina Tomko/Education Week + Canva
Law & Courts Trump Says Title IX Excludes Trans Girls. The Supreme Court Could Weigh In Next
It's the flip side of a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision upholding state laws that bar transgender girls.
7 min read
Becky Pepper-Jackson prepares to throw a discus Tuesday, April 7, 2026, at Bridgeport High School in Bridgeport, W.VA.
Becky Pepper-Jackson prepares to throw a discus on April 7, 2026, at Bridgeport High School in Bridgeport, W.Va. Jackson's challenge of a West Virginia law barring transgender girls from girls' athletic teams ended up before the Supreme Court, which upheld the state's law. Now, the court could take on the question of whether Title IX requires that transgender athletes be excluded from teams that match their gender identity.
John Raby/AP