Federal

Congress Gets Involved in School Beverage Debate

By Christina A. Samuels — October 09, 2007 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Both nutrition advocates and the soft-drink industry claimed victory last year when they announced a plan to stop selling full-calorie, sugary drinks in schools by 2009.

Nutrition groups said the agreement would strike a blow at childhood obesity and make schools models of good food habits for students. Beverage makers, meanwhile, had a chance to show their commitment to good citizenship and children’s health.

In fact, say industry representatives, the agreement has worked out so well that the voluntary guidelines should be written into a school nutrition bill pending in Congress, which would make them law.

But nutrition advocates say the voluntary policy, while a step in the right direction, still allows the wrong sorts of drinks to be sold to students.

Soda Substitute?

The school nutrition measure, sponsored by Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, and Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, is being considered as part of the much larger 2007 farm bill. The school provisions would call for the Department of Agriculture to update its decades-old standards on the nutritional quality of food and drinks sold outside of the cafeteria during the school day. Current federal law and regulations only address foods sold during school lunch periods. The rules don’t address beverage and other vending machines outside the cafeteria.

Drink Debate

Voluntary beverage-sales guidelines for high schools bar full-calorie sodas but allow sports drinks and so-called enhanced waters in addition to water, milk, fruit juice, and diet soda. The graphic shows nutrition information for comparable servings of certain drinks.

* Click image to enlarge.

BRIC ARCHIVE

Note: Some containers shown are larger than serving size.
SOURCE: Beverage makers

The voluntary guidelines supported by the beverage industry currently allow high schools to offer portion-controlled sports drinks such as Gatorade and Powerade, as well as a newer category of drinks known as “enhanced waters,” represented by products such as Vitaminwater, whose parent company was recently bought by the Coca-Cola Co. for $4 billion, and Propel Fitness Water, owned by PepsiCo Inc.

“We have opinion surveys that suggest that people support [enhanced waters and sports drinks] being offered, as long as they’re offered at an appropriate beverage size,” said Susan K. Neely, the president and chief executive officer of the American Beverage Association, a Washington-based trade group for the major beverage producers.

But health advocates say such beverages are thinly disguised sugar water. The vitamins in enhanced waters aren’t missing in most children’s diets, and the sodium included in sports drinks can be harmful, they say.

Enhanced waters and sports drinks are a “modest improvement over soda, but not exactly a healthy one,” said Margo G. Wootan, the director of nutrition policy at the Center for Science in the Public Interest, a research and advocacy group in Washington.

In April, a panel of scientists, as part of a series of changes they would like to see in school food offerings, said sports drinks should be available only for high school students who are engaging in vigorous exercise for an hour or more. And enhanced waters don’t have a place in schools, said Dr. Virginia A. Stallings, who chaired the 15-person panel that issued the report for the federal Institute of Medicine.

“We want children to get the whole food,” said Dr. Stallings, a professor of pediatrics at the University of Pennsylvania. “We don’t want to take the vitamin C and the calcium and put it in a sparkling water.”

When the panel made its recommendations, Sen. Harkin, the chairman of the Senate Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Committee, said they should be used to guide federal policy.

“The voluntary guidelines agreed to by the snack-food and beverage industries in the past year were a good first step. I applauded them, and believe that they were agreed to in good faith, but they are unenforceable,” he said in a statement earlier this year. “In addition, the [Institute of Medicine] recommendations are stronger than the negotiated guidelines to which the food industry agreed and grounded in science.”

The farm bill is currently under consideration in the Senate agriculture committee.

The debate over federal beverage guidelines is just the latest battle in efforts to address childhood obesity.

Meeting Goals

Though carbonated beverages are still the most popular drinks offered by the industry, the consumption of sports drinks and of fruit juices and juice drinks is growing, said John Sicher, the editor and publisher of the trade journal Beverage Digest.

These alternatives to carbonated drinks are also a growing part of the mix of beverages offered in schools. The voluntary policy brokered by beverage distributors and the Alliance for a Healthier Generation—a partnership between the William J. Clinton Foundation and the American Heart Association—allow such drinks to be offered to high school students, along with water, diet soda, low-fat and nonfat milk, and 100 percent juice. Under the policy, middle schools and elementary schools may offer only water, milk, and 100 percent juice.

The American Beverage Association released a report last month showing that after the first year under the voluntary agreement, full-calorie sodas declined in share of the beverage mix sold at schools from 46.9 percent in 2004 to 32.1 percent this year. Water, including enhanced waters, increased in share from 11.5 percent to 21.5 percent in that period, while sports drinks increased from 12.8 percent to 18.7 percent of the mix.

“The whole policy is geared towards reducing the amount of calories in schools. The progress is going in the right direction,” said Ms. Neely of the beverage-industry group.

Ms. Wootan, of the Center for Science in the Public Interest, said in some ways the debate over enhanced waters and sports drinks is a good one—“it shows a move away from sodas,” she said.

The center could support having the voluntary guidelines written into law, if more restrictions were placed on the availability of sports drinks and enhanced waters, Ms. Wootan said. It could also support leaving the restrictions ultimately up to the Agriculture Department.

“Which approach we use is largely up to the food and beverage industries,” Ms. Wootan said.

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Assessment
3 Key Strategies for Prepping for State Tests & Building Long-Term Formative Practices
Boost state test success with data-driven strategies. Join our webinar for actionable steps, collaboration tips & funding insights.
Content provided by Instructure
Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and K-12 education jubs at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Artificial Intelligence Webinar
Promoting Integrity and AI Readiness in High Schools
Learn how to update school academic integrity guidelines and prepare students for the age of AI.
Content provided by Turnitin

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Federal Trump Order Tells Linda McMahon to 'Facilitate' Education Department's Closure
An executive order the president signed Thursday directs Education Secretary Linda McMahon to prepare the 45-year-old agency for shutdown.
4 min read
President Donald Trump holds up a signed executive order alongside Secretary of Education Linda McMahon in the East Room of the White House in Washington, Thursday, March 20, 2025.
President Donald Trump holds up a signed executive order alongside Secretary of Education Linda McMahon in the East Room of the White House in Washington, Thursday, March 20, 2025.
Ben Curtis/AP
Federal Opinion ‘Diversity’ Isn’t a Dirty Word: Why Politicians Are Scapegoating DEI
The language may be new, but we’ve seen these same tactics used to attack racial equality for decades.
Janel George
5 min read
Flag of the USA, painted on grunge distressed planks of wood, signifying dismantling or building back up
Yamac Beyter/iStock
Federal Trump Admin. Cuts Library Funding. What It Means for Students
In an executive order last week, the Trump administration mandated the reduction of seven agencies, including one that funds libraries around the country: the Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS).
5 min read
President Donald Trump signs an executive order in the Oval Office at the White House, Monday, Feb. 10, 2025, in Washington.
President Donald Trump signs an executive order in the Oval Office at the White House, Monday, Feb. 10, 2025, in Washington.
Alex Brandon/AP
Federal The Ed. Dept. Axed Its Office of Ed Tech. What That Means for Schools
The office helped districts navigate new and emerging technology affecting schools.
A small group of diverse middle school students sit at their desks with personal laptops in front of each one as they work during a computer lab.
E+/Getty