Federal

America’s Children Don’t Have a Federal Right to Education. Will That Ever Change?

By Mark Lieberman — October 24, 2023 6 min read
Kimberly Robinson speaks at the kickoff event for the new Education Rights Institute at the University of Virginia School of Law in Charlottesville, Va., on Oct. 16, 2023.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

More than four decades ago, a young girl was breezing through 3rd grade, but she craved a deeper challenge.

Her brother, meanwhile, was experiencing bullying. During a walk home from school one day, a group of bullies followed her and her brother all the way home and nearly attacked them before backing off.

That incident, and the girl’s disillusionment, was the final straw. The girl’s parents sacrificed jobs and relationships to uproot their lives, bringing her and her brother to a new state and a new school district. The girl found herself in the middle of the pack academically, but she embraced the challenge and she worked hard to chart an ambitious path to a law career that eventually included studying under the civil rights leader Julian Bond at the University of Virginia and graduating from Harvard Law School.

That young girl was Kimberly Jenkins Robinson, now a professor of education law and public policy at the University of Virginia School of Law, and one of the nation’s leading advocates for a federal right to a high-quality K-12 education—the kind she might have missed, if not for her parents’ ability and willingness to move.

She shared her story earlier this month during a kickoff event for the Education Rights Institute, a new research and engagement organization she’s spearheading from within the law school. But she hopes others won’t have to follow in her footsteps.

“No family should ever have to move to get a high-quality education,” Robinson said during a launch event for the institute on Oct. 16.

The institute, funded initially with nearly $5 million in private donations, will produce original research and provide school districts with resources and guidance on their students’ existing civil rights protections. It joins recently announced nonprofit organizations like Brown’s Promise and the forthcoming EdFund that are pushing for systemic reforms to how America’s schools are funded.

Nearly every state’s constitution includes a right for all children within state lines to receive a free and adequate education. Those rights have been the subject of dozens of lawsuits in recent years as school districts, advocacy groups, parents, and even students have argued, based on those constitutional guarantees, that states need to provide more resources to ensure schools can live up to that commitment.

But the U.S. Constitution contains no such assurance.

In Robinson’s view, that should change, either by law or judicial ruling. She’s written two books on the subject and has a third one in the works. She even hopes to produce a related documentary modeled after Ava DuVernay’s “13th.” That film examines the system of mass incarceration that followed the 1865 passage of the 13th Amendment, which banned slavery nationwide.

Education Week interviewed Robinson twice in recent months for her thoughts on progress toward a federal right to education. The following interview has been edited for length and clarity.

Is a federal right to education within reach?

We’re closer than you may think. We do have an array of federal education rights that we did not have 50 years ago. Those are rights for everything from students with disabilities, due process, rights to be free of race discrimination. We have definitely moved toward recognizing an array of federal rights for students.

A federal right to education would be the right that makes the other rights meaningful. If you don’t have a right to a high-quality education, it’s less important how someone denies you access to education if it’s not a high-quality education that you’re receiving.

With that said, I think there’s still a significant way to travel. I do not think this current Supreme Court would recognize a federal right to education. Given the opportunity, they would reaffirm Rodriguez (the 1973 verdict rejecting the notion that funding schools through local property taxes violates the Constitution).

But the court is not the only arbiter of federal rights. Congress can make laws that offer rights.

It’s the basic right of human dignity to have a right to education. It’s the essence of our humanity. There’s just a compelling case for every child having access to a high-quality education. There are many, many students who get a truly low-quality education, and a whole bunch of others who get a mediocre education. In the wealthiest nation in the world, students should have a guarantee of a high-quality education.

See Also

Kanya Redd, 15, explores an exhibit on segregation at the Martin Luther King, Jr. National Historical Park Visitor's Center on April 18, 2023 in Atlanta. The new cultural exchange initiative is sponsored by Martha's Table, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit committed to expanding opportunity and economic mobility. Approximately 75% of the participants traveled by plane for the first time to get to Atlanta.
Kanya Redd, 15, explores an exhibit on segregation at the Martin Luther King, Jr. National Historical Park Visitor's Center on April 18, 2023 in Atlanta. A new initiative is aiming to combine advocacy and legal strategies to increase school funding and support efforts to create more racially and socioeconomically balanced schools.
Nicole Craine/AP Images for Martha's Table

In your travels, how often do you encounter people who think America’s children already have a federal right to education?

People don’t know that it doesn’t exist.

There are state guarantees, but even if the language is very strong, the enforcement of it and the meaning of it can be tepid. They lack the force that’s needed to demand a high-quality education. Part of it is that many courts defer to the legislature, which is dictated by politics and the needs of their districts, not the best interests of the entire state or commonwealth. Because of that, you get the haves who want to hold what they have, and the have-nots not having the leverage to get more.

School finance litigation has helped to get access for those who are lacking high-quality education. That has not been enough.

How do states’ recent efforts around private school choice bolster or challenge the notion of a federal right to education?

Because of Supreme Court precedent that gives parents the right to direct the education of their child, parents do have a right to opt out of the public school. Some of those parents are making that choice to exit schools that are failing their children. And blaming a parent who says, ‘My kid’s not being served well so I’m going to pull my child,’ is pointing the finger at the wrong thing.

School choice can, and in some places does, exist within public schools, too. I think that you can have school choice that is simply aiming to help those parents who are trapped into a low-quality school have options. We need to have a system that serves all students well. That will draw in more parents.

See Also

Stock image of a gavel on top of a pile of money.
iStock/Getty Images

I think that the proliferation of private school choice could undermine our public school system. When 90 percent of the students are in the public school system, we should make sure it’s a very high-quality one. Even if that number stays at 10 percent who choose to opt out, you just want to avoid it being because families felt that their children weren’t being served.

I think school choice is going to persist, but the focus of the [Education Rights Institute] is on making sure public schools are strong and of high quality. We aren’t an institute that’s going to focus on denigrating school choice, but it’s not part of our mission to focus on school choice.

Even if a federal right to education is still a long way off, what do you hope the institute will accomplish?

One thing that troubles me about education is that much of the public doesn’t understand educational opportunity gaps, the nature and scope of them. That’s part of why we don’t have greater support for systemic reform. There’s not a deep understanding of how broken our education system is, and I wanted to close that knowledge gap.

And then another thing is helping people understand that we can choose to build a better system, we just have to decide that that’s what we want. The longer we choose not to provide a better system, the more it costs, in terms of economic and democratic and justice costs for the system we have right now, and the divides that we have along race and class and ZIP code.

We do have an array of federal education rights that we did not have 50 years ago. ... A federal right to education would be the right that makes the other rights meaningful.

And then finally I want school districts to pay greater attention to Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, particularly in this current moment. There are federal obligations around race and equity that districts have already committed to, including in the states where they’re pushed to do things that might be in competition with that.

The conversation about opportunity gaps has been growing in recent years. Is it moving outside of the nonprofit scholarly world? I’m not so sure. Is it an everyday conversation at the dinner table? Can we present it in a way that anyone on the street can understand it? The data show big racial divides around understanding opportunity gaps. That is one of the things I want to change.

Events

School Climate & Safety K-12 Essentials Forum Strengthen Students’ Connections to School
Join this free event to learn how schools are creating the space for students to form strong bonds with each other and trusted adults.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Reading & Literacy Webinar
Creating Confident Readers: Why Differentiated Instruction is Equitable Instruction
Join us as we break down how differentiated instruction can advance your school’s literacy and equity goals.
Content provided by Lexia Learning
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
IT Infrastructure & Management Webinar
Future-Proofing Your School's Tech Ecosystem: Strategies for Asset Tracking, Sustainability, and Budget Optimization
Gain actionable insights into effective asset management, budget optimization, and sustainable IT practices.
Content provided by Follett Learning

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Federal Miguel Cardona in the Hot Seat: 4 Takeaways From a Contentious House Hearing
FAFSA, rising antisemitism, and Title IX dominated questioning at a U.S. House hearing with Education Secretary Miguel Cardona.
6 min read
Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona testifies during a House Committee on Education and Workforce hearing on Capitol Hill, Tuesday, May 7, 2024, in Washington.
U.S. Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona testifies during a House Committee on Education and Workforce hearing on Capitol Hill on May 7 in Washington.
Mariam Zuhaib/AP
Federal Arming Teachers Could Cause 'Accidents and More Tragedy,' Miguel Cardona Says
"This is not in my opinion a smart option,” the education secretary said at an EdWeek event.
4 min read
U.S. Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona speaks during Education Week’s 2024 Leadership Symposium at the Hyatt Regency Crystal City in Arlington, Va., on May 2, 2024.
U.S. Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona speaks during Education Week’s 2024 Leadership Symposium at the Hyatt Regency Crystal City in Arlington, Va., on May 2, 2024.
Sam Mallon/Education Week
Federal Opinion Should Migrant Families Pay Tuition for Public School?
The answer must reflect an outlook that is pro-immigration, pro-compassion, and pro-law and order, writes Michael J. Petrilli.
Michael J. Petrilli
4 min read
Image of a pencil holder filled with a variety of colored pencils that match the background with international flags.
Laura Baker/Education Week via Canva
Federal New Title IX Rule Could Actually Simplify Some Things for Districts, Lawyers Say
School districts could field more harassment complaints, but they can streamline how they handle them, according to legal experts.
7 min read
Illustration of checklist.
F. Sheehan for Education Week + iStock / Getty Images Plus