School & District Management Opinion

Graduation-Rate Calculations, the 9th Grade Bulge, and Race

By Michael Holzman — November 07, 2006 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Many aspects of American public education that attract attention for one reason or another, no matter what their seeming subject, turn out at some level to be about the American Dilemma: race. Take, for example, the current set of discussions concerning how to calculate high school graduation rates.

One way in which the quality of schools and school systems can be compared with that of others is the rate at which students move through high school from grade 9 to graduation. This is a rather crude measure—it says little or nothing about what those students have learned—but it is useful in a sheep-and-goats way: Districts that graduate very few of their students in four years are unlikely to perform well in other ways.

The point of such a measure is comparability. We will not find it a useful comparison if some districts report dogs and goats and others report sheep and cats. High school graduation rates that include General Educational Development, or GED, credentials, for example, might be interesting, but they are not useful comparisons with those that do not.

There is now a consensus that the ideal method is to trace individual students from grade 9 through to graduation. As this system will take some time to put into place, various approximations are under consideration. The most straightforward way of approximating graduation rates is to count the students entering grade 9 one year, count those receiving diplomas four years later, and divide the former into the latter. This is, after all, what most people mean by the term “graduation rate.”

The National Center for Education Statistics recently published a study of some methods of approximating graduation rates in lieu of actual individual student data. Noting that in the aggregate there is a “bulge” in enrollments at grade 9, the NCES recommends estimating a base cohort by averaging grade 8 through grade 10 enrollments.

The grade 9 bulge is thought to be caused by the common practice of restricting promotion from grade 9 to grade 10 by an examination. In some places, this gateway is placed at grade 8, rather than at grade 9, creating a grade 8 bulge. In other places, there is no gateway. But, looking at national data, the grade 9 bulge is quite apparent and, by increasing the size of grade 9 enrollments over those of grades 8 and 10, seems to require adjustment.

Looked at more carefully, the matter is more than a problem in statistical methodology.

When data are disaggregated by race/ethnicity and gender, which was not done by the NCES study group, we find that states with large numbers of black students have large grade 9 enrollment bulges; those with smaller numbers of black students have smaller grade 9 enrollment bulges. According to NCES data for the country as a whole, nearly a third of black male students repeated grade 9, while 15 percent of white male students were forced to repeat grade 9. In many states, more than 30 percent of black male students were forced to repeat grade 9 in 2004-05 (and in New York, where 5 percent of the white male students were held back, the figure for male black students was 44 percent).

More research is needed (as researchers always say), but it does appear that the grade 9 “bulge” is largely attributable to the failure to educate black students (and, to a lesser extent, Hispanic students). These deleterious effects are concentrated in states where black students are concentrated. (Where there are lower concentrations of black students, black graduation rates are higher.) “Smoothing the bulge” statistically, as advocated by the NCES and others, conceals this effect and therefore makes estimated cohort graduation rates less useful as an analytical tool.

This is a matter of concern on both ends of the causation arrow. Why, in these states, are black boys so ill-prepared for high school that a third or more must repeat grade 9? And, given the dropout rates in these states for black male students, is this policy of erecting a grade 9 gateway useful educationally, or simply effective as a way to push male black students out of school?

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the November 08, 2006 edition of Education Week as Graduation-Rate Calculations, the 9th Grade Bulge, and Race


Jobs Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and other jobs in K-12 education at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Mathematics Webinar
What is it About Math? Making Math Figure-Out-Able
Join Pam Harris for an engaging session challenging how we approach math, resulting in real world math that is “figure-out-able” for anyone.
Content provided by hand2mind
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Reading & Literacy Webinar
Science of Reading: Emphasis on Language Comprehension
Dive into language comprehension through a breakdown of the Science of Reading with an interactive demonstration.
Content provided by Be GLAD

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School & District Management Opinion 5 Reasons Why Education Leaders Avoid Controversial Topics
Understanding why we shy away from challenging conversations can be a path toward empathy and an opportunity for learning.
4 min read
Let's brainstorm!
Created on Canva
School & District Management Most Superintendents Try to Avoid Politics. This Group Encourages Them to Lean In
Superintendents increasingly face politically tricky situations. A new collaborative hopes to support them.
3 min read
Illustration of person riding a unicycle on a tightrope over shark infested waters.
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty Images
School & District Management Superintendent of the Year Focuses on How to ‘Do More’ in Minnesota
The 2024 winner of the national honor didn't want to spend pandemic relief funds "in the way that we’ve always spent our money."
2 min read
Joe Gothard, superintendent of St. Paul Public Schools stands for a portrait at Como Park High School in St. Paul, Minn., on Aug. 21, 2021, where new federal school funding will help to hire staff, buy books and be used for building renovations.
Joe Gothard, superintendent of St. Paul Public Schools stands for a portrait at Como Park High School in St. Paul, Minn., on Aug. 21, 2021. Gothard was named the 2024 National Superintendent of the Year on Thursday by AASA, The School Superintendents' Association.
Andy Clayton-King/AP
School & District Management The Average U.S. School Building Dates Back to the End of the Vietnam War
New federal data highlight widely varying ages and offerings in school buildings nationwide.
4 min read
School Renovation in Washington Heights, Chicago
E+ / Getty