Opinion
School & District Management Opinion

Charter-Management Organizations: Expansion, Survival, and Impact

By Thomas Toch — October 23, 2009 7 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

In the decade since they emerged on the education landscape, nonprofit networks of charter schools called charter-management organizations, or CMOs, have built some of the biggest brands in education—the Knowledge Is Power Program, Aspire, Green Dot Public Schools, Uncommon Schools—and won plaudits from the likes of Oprah Winfrey, The New York Times Magazine, and “60 Minutes.”

U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan is now poised to give them a central role in the federal government’s multibillion-dollar school reform campaign. He has named leaders of the CMO movement to key posts in his department and has pledged to make “big bets” on the highest-performing charter networks with the expectation that they’ll produce large numbers of outstanding new schools for disadvantaged students.

Related Commentary

In “Charter-Management Organizations: More Pluses Than Minuses” Priscilla Wohlstetter, Joanna Smith, and Michelle Nayfack say that development of Charter-Management Organizations is a positive for the charter movement.

Read this related commentary.

But the research for a report on CMOs that I’ve produced for the think tank Education Sector reveals that many of these organizations are going to be hard-pressed to deliver the many schools that Duncan wants from them. Discussions with dozens of CMO executives and other experts, an examination of CMO business plans, consultant reports, and other documents, and visits to over a dozen schools run by prominent CMOs in different parts of the country make clear that a host of challenges—the need to find and finance school buildings, the expense of educating impoverished students successfully, the difficulty of recruiting high-performing teachers and principals, and, in many instances, strong opposition from traditional public educators—has left many CMOs working hard to sustain themselves academically and financially.

BRIC ARCHIVE

Since their inception in the late 1990s as more politically palatable alternatives to for-profit education-management companies like Edison Schools Inc., CMOs have required substantial subsidies from foundations and other sources of philanthropy, and, more recently, have suffered heavily at the hands of a recession that has battered state and local education budgets. The bulk of the philanthropy has come from national foundations—Walton, Gates, Broad, Fisher, and Dell—and has resulted in some four dozen charter networks’ opening about 350 schools with some 100,000 seats over the past decade. This is a long ways from the 5,000 failing public schools that Secretary Duncan hopes to fix or replace.

Even with an infusion of federal funding, it would be difficult for CMOs to expand much more rapidly without compromising the quality of their schools. The risk, charter school finance experts warn, is that the Obama administration’s ambitious initiatives could end up leading to the opening of many marginal schools by overextended charter networks.

The best CMOs have produced outstanding results in some of the nation’s toughest neighborhoods, educating their students to sharply higher levels than traditional urban public schools. But the record of leading CMOs over the past decade suggests that absent changes in the evolution of charter networks, it’s likely to be difficult to sustain and replicate the strong results some CMOs have produced.

It would, of course, be much less difficult for CMOs to open more high-quality and financially sustainable schools if they received as much public funding as traditional public schools and didn’t have to find and finance their own facilities. And it would be easier to balance their budgets if they weren’t trying to expand.

But several key features of successful CMO-run schools themselves contribute to the financial difficulties these charters face, because they are expensive. To promote strong relationships between students and teachers, most of the schools, for example, are smaller than traditional public schools, and thus more costly to run per pupil. Many of them have longer school days and years. And many build out their schools a single grade at a time, a costly strategy that CMO leaders say is necessary to create a strong sense of community and a culture of achievement for the schools’ disadvantaged students.

Getting good results also has required CMOs to spend more heavily than they had expected to support their schools. They had hoped to follow the lean-central-administration model of parochial school systems, relying on talented school leaders with ample autonomy to get results. But that has proved difficult to do.

The pressure CMOs feel to make a compelling case for charter schools in a difficult political climate also has led to spending more on both external help and extra staff members in schools. The result has been larger and more expensive CMO central offices. Spending on central administration averaged 18 percent of revenue among the 17 major CMOs funded by the NewSchools Venture Fund in the 2007-08 school year, even though a number of the organizations’ business plans require them to reduce central spending to between 6 percent and 8 percent of revenue to become financially self-sustaining. Edison Schools struggled unsuccessfully with the same challenge for nearly a decade before the company’s value plunged.

It's not likely that enough philanthropy is going to flow to CMOs in the coming years to permit them to expand at a substantially faster rate. To the contrary, some major funders have signaled that they plan to focus more on quality than quantity.

Having lots of young teachers has helped. The 17 CMOs in the NewSchools portfolio reported last year that 40 percent of their teachers had been in the profession for two years or less, and only 13 percent had more than seven years of experience; in contrast, teachers in traditional public schools average 14 years of experience. The impact on CMOs’ bottom line is dramatic. A recent study by Massachusetts education officials found that the state’s charter schools spend an average of 25 percent less per teacher than traditional public schools in the state, a substantial savings given the prominence of salaries and benefits in school budgets.

But CMOs increasingly face the challenge of either paying their teachers more as they gain seniority, or churning through teachers and making it tougher to sustain their schools’ powerful cultures—a choice that puts the schools’ dual bottom lines of quality instruction and fiscal sustainability in conflict.

That conflict is playing out in another important way. Student attrition is high in CMO schools, fueled by higher standards, long hours, and transient families. A study of four San Francisco Bay Area KIPP middle schools found that 60 percent of entering students departed before graduating. The loss of revenue from so many departing students is devastating, but the price of bringing in replacement students is also high: They are typically behind academically and make it tougher for the organizations to post strong academic results.

To help manage their finances, many CMOs have limited programs in art, music, athletics, and foreign languages. Yet it has still taken more than half a billion dollars in philanthropy over the past decade to get the CMO movement to where it is today. And that money has been concentrated in the nation’s largest metropolitan areas. It’s not likely that enough philanthropy is going to flow to CMOs in the coming years to permit them to expand at a substantially faster rate. To the contrary, some major funders have signaled that they plan to focus more on quality than quantity. And a number of leading CMOs have struggled to prove that they can run on public funding alone, as many of them hope to do to demonstrate the scalability of their school designs.

Some, however, would require subsidies in many places even if they had full public funding and didn’t have to pay for buildings. States and school systems in many parts of the country simply don’t spend enough to pay for KIPP and other intensive school designs. CMOs also struggle to make ends meet in higher-spending jurisdictions. In the District of Columbia, the highly regarded DC Prep network has resorted to hiring a collection agency to track down nearly $40,000 a year in unpaid lunch monies. As much as anything, the labor-intensive work of the best CMOs over the past decade makes a strong case for increasing funding for disadvantaged students.

The best charter-management organizations have attracted many talented people to the cause of public school improvement. They have demonstrated that disadvantaged students can be educated to higher levels. And they have served as laboratories of reform. But a burst of federal stimulus funding isn’t going to guarantee large numbers of high-performing, financially sustainable CMO schools. That would require a restructuring of school finance and closer working relationships between public school systems and charter networks than either has been willing to embrace. But with strong financial incentives from the U.S. Department of Education to do so, school systems might be willing to grant partner CMOs full funding, buildings, and the school design and staffing autonomy that have contributed to high-performing CMOs’ success.

Ultimately, urban school systems will lose an important catalyst for reform, and charter networks won’t be able to sustain themselves into the future, unless the two sides collaborate rather than compete.

A version of this article appeared in the October 28, 2009 edition of Education Week as Expansion, Survival, and Impact

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Curriculum Webinar
Strategies for Incorporating SEL into Curriculum
Empower students to thrive. Learn how to integrate powerful social-emotional learning (SEL) strategies into the classroom.
Content provided by Be GLAD
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
Leadership in Education: Building Collaborative Teams and Driving Innovation
Learn strategies to build strong teams, foster innovation, & drive student success.
Content provided by Follett Learning
School & District Management K-12 Essentials Forum Principals, Lead Stronger in the New School Year
Join this free virtual event for a deep dive on the skills and motivation you need to put your best foot forward in the new year.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School & District Management What the Research Says 5 Things Schools Can Do This Summer to Improve Student Attendance Next Year
Schools can get a jump on student attendance during the school year by using data, leveraging summer programs, and connecting with families.
6 min read
Julian Gresham, 12, left, works in a group to program a Bee-Bot while in their fifth grade summer school class Monday, June 14, 2021, at Goliad Elementary School. Bee-bots and are new to Ector County Independent School District and help to teach students basic programming skills like sequencing, estimation and problem-solving.
Julian Gresham, 12, left, works on a robotics programming activity in a 5th-grade summer school class June 14, 2021, at Goliad Elementary School in Ector County, Texas. Active summer programs may improve students' attendance during the school year.
Jacob Ford/Odessa American via AP
School & District Management Grad Rates Soared at a School Few Wanted to Attend. How It Happened
Leaders at this Florida high school have "learned to be flexible" to improve graduation rates.
8 min read
Student hanging on a tearing graduate cap tassel
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty
School & District Management Opinion Don’t Just Listen to the Loudest Voices: Resources for Ed. Leaders
These resources can help school and district leaders communicate with their communities.
Jennifer Perry Cheatham & Jenny Portillo-Nacu
5 min read
A pair of hands type on a blank slate of keys that are either falling apart or coming together on a bed of sharpened pencils.  Leadership resources.
Raul Arias for Education Week
School & District Management The Harm of School Closures Can Last a Lifetime, New Research Shows
The short-term effects on students when their schools close have been well documented. New research examines the long-term impact.
5 min read
Desks and chairs are stacked in an empty classroom after the permanent closure of Queen of the Rosary Catholic Academy in Brooklyn borough of New York on Aug. 6, 2020.
Desks and chairs are stacked in an empty classroom after the permanent closure of Queen of the Rosary Catholic Academy in Brooklyn borough of New York on Aug. 6, 2020. A new study examines the long-term effects on students whose schools close.
Jessie Wardarski/AP