Published Online: August 1, 2013

Indiana Grade-Change Revelation Vexes Florida Schools Chief

Indiana Superintendent of Public Instruction Dr. Tony Bennett speaks during a news conference in Indianapolis back in 2011.
—AJ Mast/AP-File

Controversy over changes that Florida Commissioner of Education Tony Bennett made to Indiana’s A-F school accountability system last year when he was that state’s K-12 chief could complicate his policy challenges in Florida—including how to keep the Sunshine State’s common-core effort on track and deal with fallout from a change to its own A-F system.

Mr. Bennett’s handling of an Indianapolis charter school’s mediocre initial grade last September has led to allegations that he initiated a frantic and improper overhaul of the entire A-F system in Indiana just to boost the grade of that school, operated by a philanthropist who also has given him political donations. Mr. Bennett has denied any wrongdoing.

More recently, in his current job, Mr. Bennett shepherded through a change to Florida’s A-F grading system for schools intended to limit the consequences from an expected drop in grades as the Common Core State Standards and tests aligned with them are phased in through the 2014-15 school year. And he is facing pressure from Florida elected officials to drop out of a federally funded consortium developing common-core-aligned tests.

“He has a lot of different things he’s juggling. And this does not help,” Tom Loveless, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution’s Brown Center on Education Policy, said of the Indiana controversy.

Mr. Loveless said the Indiana revelations also highlight the importance of states’ protecting their accountability systems from the appearance of political influence. “You have to be very careful that you wall off accountability, which should not be influenced by elected officials, from the politics of the state,” he said. “Until you do that, you’re going to have these ethical questions.”

Trail of Emails

See Also
Read the email exchange Tony Bennett had with his staff regarding Christel House Academy and it's grade from the state.

The Indiana firestorm was ignited this week when the Associated Press published emails from September 2012, when Mr. Bennett was still Indiana’s elected state superintendent. At that time, they show, Mr. Bennett and top aides learned that the Christel House Academy charter school would earn a C grade for the 2011-12 school year—largely because of low 10th grade algebra scores.

That prospect set off a flurry of activity by the state education department to see how it could alter the A-F system, an accountability measure that Mr. Bennett had championed.

Mr. Bennett had previously assured the school’s operator, Christel DeHaan, and Indiana Speaker of the House Brian Bosma, a Republican, that the school would receive an A grade. Given the mediocre scores for Christel House, Mr. Bennett wrote to aides that his pledges amounted to “repeated lies.”

Subsequent email correspondence shows that Mr. Bennett and staff members discussed and ultimately made changes to school grading as it related to Christel House and other schools, although it remains unclear exactly what those changes were. The school’s score ultimately rose to an A, or a 3.75 on the scale.

Ms. DeHaan contributed a total of $130,000 to Mr. Bennett’s political campaigns in 2008 and 2012. Campaign-finance records show that for the reporting period from last Oct. 23—after the email exchanges obtained by the Associated Press occurred—through the end of 2012, she gave Mr. Bennett’s campaign $15,000.Requires Adobe Acrobat Reader She has also contributed to Indiana Democrats and to President Barack Obama.

In a July 30 conference call with reporters, Mr. Bennett denied that he had acted improperly. In fact, he said, officials changed the grades for Christel House and 12 other schools that were “unfairly penalized” for not having graduation statistics. At the time, 10th grade was Christel House’s highest grade level.

Mr. Bennett also said that confidence in Florida schools’ A-F grades shouldn’t be compromised as a result of the Indiana disclosures.

“It has never been, and it won’t be, about political donors or making charter schools or private schools look good,” he said.

Florida Debates

Meanwhile, Mr. Bennett, who was hired to lead the Florida schools after losing his Indiana re-election bid, has been dealing with the aftermath of the Florida state board’s July 16 vote to alter the A-F accountability system (on his recommendationRequires Adobe Acrobat Reader) so that no individual school’s grade will drop by more than one letter grade in one year for the 2013-14 and 2014-15 school years.

The 2013-14 year is the first time the common core will be implemented in all Florida grades, and 2014-15 is the first scheduled year for new assessments aligned with the common core.

“I believe the transition to [the common core] will be an opportunity to provide greater transparency in our state accountability system,” Mr. Bennett wrote to the state board.

Florida’s A-F system was enacted in 1999 and supported by then-Gov. Jeb Bush, a Republican. Patricia Levesque, the executive director of the Foundation for Florida’s Future, a K-12 advocacy group chaired by Mr. Bush, had written a July 15 letter to the board opposing the change.

But in an interview, Mr. Bennett denied the change represented a “relaxation” of accountability along the lines of the state’s decision to lower the cutoff score on its writing test last year, following a drop in student performance.

Mr. Bennett also has had to deal with opposition to common-core assessments from Senate President Don Gaetz and Speaker of the House Will Weatherford, both Republicans, who said the state should drop out of the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers, or PARCC, testing consortium. (On a national level, U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., also voiced opposition to the common core late last month.)

Mr. Bennett said the state is weighing a potential “Plan B” alternative to the PARCC assessment, but said that support for the standards in Florida remains strong. So far, no legislation to repeal the common core in Florida has been introduced.



Sept. 12, 2012 Emails From Tony Bennett



Vol. 32, Issue 37

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Login | Register
Ground Rules for Posting
We encourage lively debate, but please be respectful of others. Profanity and personal attacks are prohibited. By commenting, you are agreeing to abide by our user agreement.
All comments are public.

Back to Top Back to Top

Most Popular Stories

Viewed

Emailed

Recommended

Commented