Push Is On for Common Ways to Identify ELLs

Students change classes last week at Abraham Lincoln High School in San Francisco, where students who are English-learners come from a variety of backgrounds. In California, more than 1,000 school districts can make their own rules for deciding when an English-learner has reached proficiency in the language.

—Ramin Rahimian for Education Week

By Lesli A. Maxwell

The many ways of identifying which students are English-learners and when they reach proficiency in the language could meld into a more uniform process as a result of the move to common standards and assessments, a profound shift that could drive changes in instruction and provision of resources, experts say.

As two big groups of states work to design shared assessments for the new standards, they are laboring to establish shared definitions of what it means to be an English-language learner and when those students no longer need language instruction. That would represent a massive change from current practice, which finds districts and states using unique definitions for ELLs and widely varying criteria for reclassifying them as fluent.

Getting states to agree on such a complex and often politicized issue will require a deliberate, multiyear process, state policy officials...