Teaching Opinion

Student Self-Assessment Practices That Work

By Starr Sackstein — May 26, 2016 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Understanding how we learn best is one of the keys to growth as human beings. This essential metacognitive skill is not innate and must be modeled and taught in school starting as early as possible.

The way it looks for different age groups will be different, obviously as younger students are not always cognitively ready to do this kind of thinking. However with the right scaffolds in place, reflection and self-assessment can be a rich way to extend the depth of independent learning and also aid in informing the teacher about valuable data around growth and understanding.

As we put more and more of the control into student hands, it’s not enough to just tell them to reflect or self-assess; it is imperative that we give them tools to do these practices well and then offer many opportunities to practice and get better at it.

Here are some ways teachers can start to implement meaningful self-assessment into classes:

  • At the beginning of a unit, consider having students set goals for themselves based on projected outcomes and objectives. These goals will drive reflection and tracking of progress throughout each student’s journey.
  • Scaffold the process by starting off with a google form with a list of questions that walk them through the process of thinking about their learning like:

    • What do you think this assignment was about? or What was your understanding of the assignment?
    • What did you have to do?
    • What steps did you take to complete the assignment?
    • What kinds of challenges did you face? How did you overcome these challenges?
    • What did you do well in this assignment? How do you know?
    • Did you meet the success criteria? How do you know?
    • Wording for these questions will likely be adjusted for the age of the students you are working with.
  • It’s a good idea to have students reflecting throughout the process. Not just at the end. So consider allowing them to think about each day’s learning as an exit ticket or something they keep in their notebooks for daily summary. In their own words they can think about what they learned in class that day and how it connects to something they learned before or how it could connect to other skills or subject areas.
  • Once students get a handle on these kinds of questions on a sheet or form, ask students to start sharing their learning in other formats, more narrative. Some will prefer to write, others may prefer to use multimedia options like Voxer or Screencast-o-matic.
  • At the end of major assignments, students should be asked to reflect on their learning and self-assess what they’ve learned based on exemplars and standards. As they are working through assignments, standards should be transparently connected to the learning outcomes and while they are learning specific skills, the teacher should help with the connections to the standards. It makes sense for younger students to rewrite the standards in “kid-friendly” language or if students are too young, the teacher can simplify the standards so they understand, keeping each part simple.
  • Self-assessments based on standards should be written like an argument paper (also aligning with the Common Core). When they say they are approaching, meeting or exceeding the standards, the student should show in their work support for this assessment. Where in their own work is there evidence of the skill at work? Showing students examples of what this looks like and providing them feedback early in the year to develop these skills is also extremely helpful. For example when I read student self-assessments and reflections, I comment on the quality of each paragraph in the narrative. If they did a good job explaining what was expected on the assignment, I write “good understanding of the task” while highlighting part of the work. If there standards aren’t evident, I might say, “Good evidence of process, but need to tie evidence of learning to the standards. Make sure to review the assignment sheet where standards are listed.” Sometimes I even share student examples if I notice a child isn’t getting it.

Over all, self-assessment is a valuable tool as it gives students the ability to really consider their learning and equally as importantly, share that understanding with the teacher. Once we understand what students know and can do, both demonstrated in the work and their ideas about the work, we can adjust instruction and/or class pacing as needed. The more adept students become with this tool, the better tailored class time and assessments can be.

How do you teach students to self-assess? What is the greatest lesson you’ve learned for teaching them to do so? Please share

The opinions expressed in Work in Progress are strictly those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Editorial Projects in Education, or any of its publications.