Science Opinion

Preparing for the Real Enemy

By Charles W. Anderson — September 12, 2006 6 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Listening to politicians in both parties pander to the electorate, it’s easy to think that the overarching national energy goal can be neatly summarized in two words: cheap gas. And identifying the biggest threat to national security can be done even more succinctly: terrorism.

— Nip Rogers


But such one-dimensional rhetoric isn’t just the fault of politicians, who often are merely responding to constituents’ unrealistic expectations.

A hint of the politicians’ dilemma was buried in a May 10 New York Times-CBS News poll about the performance of U.S. elected officials on a host of policy issues.

Not surprisingly, neither President Bush nor Congress earned high marks. What startled me, though, was the response to this question: “Regardless of how you usually vote, do you think the Republican Party or the Democratic Party is more likely to see to it that gasoline prices are low?”

Fifty-seven percent of the respondents said that the Democrats could keep prices low. Another 14 percent chose the Republicans or both parties. Seventy-one percent of Americans, in other words, see the price of gas as a political issue. This is tantamount to living in a fantasy world and ignoring both the economic law of supply and demand and the accumulating environmental damage caused by our fossil-fuel-dependent economy.

It’s not surprising that many politicians choose to respond to numbers like these with stopgap measures that delay the inevitable reckoning, hoping that something will come up in the meantime. But the root of the problem stretches beyond Washington to an electorate that can’t evaluate science-based statements. It’s time, then, for a sea change in science education in our nation’s schools.

Imagine how politicians would act differently if the public were more knowledgeable about ideas currently considered too arcane for political debate—fossil-fuel supply chains; hidden costs not included in the price we pay for a product; and the chemistry of tailpipe emissions.

That scenario remains imaginary for now, since, by every indication, the public is ill-equipped to evaluate arguments based on such ideas. Adults and children know that pollution is bad for the environment and that trees are good, but they have no idea why experts see the price of gasoline as connected to housing policies, ethanol production, or plug-in hybrids.

Blithe ignorance almost would be funny if the stakes weren’t so high.

Global climate change and environmental degradation pose a greater risk to us all than do terrorists or military and economic competition. Yet these affronts to the natural world attack in ways that make it tough to see the primary cause of obviously destructive effects—a spike in the price of gasoline, forests destroyed by drought, floods of refugees in failed nation-states unable to feed their people, and so on.

Enhancing national and global security requires preparing students to be environmentally responsible citizens.

Our schools are essential in helping to shine light on these causal chains. In fact, enhancing national and global security requires preparing students to be environmentally responsible citizens.

As consumers, our students will one day decide what kinds of cars to buy and where to live. As voters, they will decide which politicians to elect and what issues are important. As workers, they will enact the environmental practices of small companies and large corporations. As volunteers and advocates, they will decide which issues we are prepared to deal with at the grassroots level.

Unfortunately, though, the current science curriculum is not up to preparing our students to be environmentally responsible, period.

Too often, our students learn science in contexts that are connected neither to current political issues nor to students’ future societal roles. The curriculum is fragmented into tiny pieces that render the important connections invisible. And worst of all, the focus on testing and accountability has placed memorization of facts ahead of preparing students to understand the nature of science and evaluate the validity and accuracy of scientific arguments.

Public understanding of science means more than preparing students to take exams that are quickly forgotten once the scores are in. To give Earth its proper place in our political and economic debates, both citizens and leaders will have to understand some practical truths about chemistry, earth science, and biology—in addition to politics and economics, the usual proving grounds of today’s leaders.

Responsibility for such training rests with our schools, which still provide a common set of core knowledge and skills to our widest swath of society. The nature of that core knowledge is important. Specifically, for our schools to graduate students who are capable of being environmentally responsible citizens, we should change our K-12 science curriculum in two fundamental ways: by incorporating recent advances in environmental science, and by making science a communal resource for political and economic arguments.

As in much of science, barriers are coming down between traditionally separate environmental disciplines. Modern ecology, for example, now focuses on the close relationship between human and natural systems. Ecologists work with atmospheric scientists, earth scientists, and social scientists to study how human populations alter natural ecosystems. For years, university researchers routinely have built and refined computer models to explain what resources human beings extract from natural systems and what wastes we put back in. Now it’s time for a K-12 curriculum that includes this new and more-integrative approach to science.

Our students learn science in contexts that are connected neither to current political issues nor to students’ future societal roles.

We cannot anticipate which environmental issues will loom largest for our children during their lifetimes or how such issues should be addressed. So it doesn’t make sense to conceive of science education as a platform for advocating particular policies. But in an increasingly complex world, basic scientific knowledge should be a communal resource that all citizens can draw on. And for the rudimentary toolkit of scientific reasoning to be available to and respected by all citizens, science training needs to be emphasized from the earliest primary grades.

Citizens who can use the implements of science—rational inquiry, evidence-based arguments, and the like—still may disagree on moral, political, and economic grounds. But they also will be able to understand and evaluate the arguments that exist among experts, and, subsequently, to make better decisions about policy and government action. We must create a science curriculum that supports students’ use of these tools.

With such difficult issues and sharp political divisions, it’s perhaps unreasonable to think that a new ethic of shared scientific knowledge will, on its own, foster public consensus. But such an ethic may improve the chances that our politicians will engage in informed debate—and that the political process will produce reasonable decisions.

Besides, what’s the alternative? What happens if the public cannot understand even the most basic arguments among experts?

One certain outcome of staying the present course is that politicians will continue to get elected by pandering to short-term, pocketbook interests. Another, unfortunately, is that Earth will continue to change in terrifying defiance of our uneducated popular opinion.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the September 13, 2006 edition of Education Week as Preparing for the Real Enemy


This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
IT Infrastructure & Management Webinar
From Chaos to Clarity: How to Master EdTech Management and Future-Proof Your Evaluation Processes
The road to a thriving educational technology environment is paved with planning, collaboration, and effective evaluation.
Content provided by Instructure
Special Education Live Online Discussion A Seat at the Table - Special Education: Proven Interventions for Academic Success
Special education should be a launchpad, not a label. Join the conversation on how schools can better support ALL students.
Special Education K-12 Essentials Forum Innovative Approaches to Special Education
Join this free virtual event to explore innovations in the evolving landscape of special education.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Science From Our Research Center Educators: Start Early to Keep Students Engaged in STEM
The EdWeek Research Center asked teachers, principals, and district leaders how to motivate kids to pursue STEM learning.
2 min read
Photo illustration of chemistry teacher working with young student.
F. Sheehan for Education Week + E+ / Getty
Science Photos Photos: The Solar Eclipse Is the Ultimate Science Lesson
How students, teachers, and families experienced the solar eclipse.
1 min read
Yurem Rodriquez watches as the moon partially covers the sun during a total solar eclipse, as seen from Eagle Pass, Texas, on April 8, 2024.
Yurem Rodriquez watches as the moon partially covers the sun during a total solar eclipse, as seen from Eagle Pass, Texas, on April 8, 2024.
Eric Gay/AP
Science Download DIY Ideas for Safe Eclipse Viewing (Downloadable)
Here's a guide to safe, do-it-yourself ways to view next month's total eclipse, in or out of school.
1 min read
Image of a colander casting a shadow on a white paper as one way to view the eclipse using a household item.
iStock/Getty and Canva
Science Q&A How Schools Can Turn the Solar Eclipse Into an Unforgettable Science Lesson
The once-in-a-lifetime event can pique students' interest in science.
6 min read
A billboard heralding the upcoming total solar eclipse that Erie will experience is shown in Erie, Pa., on March 22, 2024.
A billboard heralding the upcoming total solar eclipse that Erie will experience is shown in Erie, Pa., on March 22, 2024.
Gene J. Puskar/AP