School Choice & Charters

The Push for School Choice Is Accelerating

By Libby Stanford — January 27, 2023 6 min read
Students and teachers from East High School in Salt Lake City walk out of school to protest the HB15 voucher bill, on Wednesday, Jan. 25, 2023. Several years of pandemic restrictions and curriculum battles have emboldened longtime advocates of funneling public funds to private and religious schools in statehouses throughout the country.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Emboldened by frustrations with pandemic-era policies and battles over what schools are teaching, conservative parents and politicians have accelerated a push for school choice policies that would funnel public funds into private schools.

Though school choice has been debated for decades, the movement is in a unique moment as advocates use parent concerns over COVID-era mask requirements; curriculum addressing race, gender, and sexuality; and library book content to bolster their argument that families should have more options outside of traditional public schools. And the school choice proposals states are considering—and, in some cases, have already passed—are more sweeping than previous iterations.

Already this year, lawmakers in at least 11 states—Idaho, Iowa, Kansas, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Texas, Utah, and Virginia—have introduced and, in some cases, passed school choice bills. Although they vary in scope, many of the bills would establish or expand private school voucher and education savings account programs that give families public funds to pay for tuition at private schools, cover the costs of homeschooling, or pay for other schooling expenses.

The resurgence of school choice action shouldn’t come as a surprise. During the 2022 midterm election cycle, 19 Republican gubernatorial candidates advocated for school choice, mostly in the form of vouchers and education savings accounts, on campaign websites. This year, seven governors so far have talked about school choice policies in their state of the state addresses, according to the Education Commission of the States.

The policies are a result of parents’ declining satisfaction with schools following the pandemic, said Jonathan Butcher, an education policy analyst for the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank that advocates for school choice policies.

“Public schools lost track of tens of thousands of kids. And, in some places … the unions were able to keep those schools closed to in-person learning even when district officials were saying they wanted teachers to come back for in-person learning,” Butcher said. “I don’t think that was lost on [parents].”

But while supporters view the policies as a key to unlocking academic opportunities for students, opponents worry they threaten public schools’ ability to operate.

Where politicians are supporting school choice

Thirty-two states and the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico have some sort of policy on the books supporting school choice, including tax credits for parents who switch to different schools, private school scholarship programs, and education savings accounts, according to EdChoice, a nonprofit that tracks school choice.

Of those states, eight have education savings accounts, in which the state gives eligible families a set amount of public funds to cover school-related costs, including private school, online learning, tutoring, community college, and college expenses. Sixteen states plus Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico have voucher programs, which are often branded as scholarships, giving students all or part of their public per-pupil funding to pay for private school, according to EdChoice.

Soon, Iowa and Utah are expected to join that list after both states’ legislatures passed bills establishing education savings account programs this week, which was also National School Choice Week. Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds signed a bill that would give families up to $7,598 each for an education savings account for private school tuition, the Des Moines Register reported. The policy would cost $345 million annually after being phased in over the next five years.

In Utah, a bill that passed both chambers of the legislature would allow up to 5,000 students to access $42 million in taxpayer-funded scholarships to attend private schools. The legislation awaits a signature from Gov. Spencer Cox, who has signaled his support, according to the Salt Lake Tribune.

There’s been action on the federal level, too. Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, recently reintroduced the Children Have Opportunities in Classrooms Everywhere, or CHOICE, Act, which would deposit Elementary and Secondary Education Act funds into education savings accounts for private schools, virtual learning, tutoring, homeschooling, therapy services, and more.

How school choice bills work

While they can take many different forms and have different names, education savings accounts and vouchers are both ultimately designed to allow families to use funds that would otherwise go to public schools to enroll their children in private schools, said Douglas Harris, director of the Center for Research on Education Access and Choice at Tulane University.

Savings accounts typically include a smaller amount of money to support educational expenses while vouchers give students a large portion or the entire amount of their per-pupil funding to cover private school costs. But now those lines are getting increasingly blurred, Harris said.

For example, the Utah bill is effectively a voucher program, but lawmakers have avoided using that term.

“The term ‘vouchers’ doesn’t poll very well,” Harris said. “But there’s no savings element to [the Utah bill]. It’s not designed for small things; it’s designed to be enough to send students to [private] school. So they’re just changing the name to make it sound better.”

The pro-school choice argument is that more options give students the chance to find an educational experience that best suits them.

“Education savings accounts are the future of learning in the United States because it allows families to find a set of education services that meet their child’s needs,” Butcher said. “We’re not just shifting all of our options into one singular solution, we’re actually opening up all of the available [options] to families with these accounts.”

Concerns mount that bills will hurt public schools

All the measures come with criticism from public school advocates, including teachers’ unions and school board associations, who say they’ll drain public schools of resources by pushing students out. The Utah Education Association vowed to fight the state’s scholarship bill after the legislature passed it this week.

“Lawmakers should focus on providing solutions to our public schools’ most urgent needs, like large class sizes, increased student behavior issues, and severe staffing shortages,” the union’s president, Renee Pinkney, said in a statement. “A voucher bill does nothing to support educators and public schools.”

Until now, school choice programs have mostly been too small to have much of an impact on traditional public schools, but as states pass more sweeping school choice policies, there is a concern that lawmakers are starting down “a slippery slope,” Harris said.

“If you make these programs big and lots of people start to use them, then you start pulling out so many families that that ultimately undermines the traditional public schools, and that’s probably right,” he said.

The impact could be especially significant on rural schools with small enrollments. In those communities, it wouldn’t take the departure of many students to have a major effect on a school’s ability to function. The policies are also harder to sell in rural areas, even among conservative voters, because of concerns about how they’ll change community culture and climate if students leave local schools.

“Public schools are really a center of life in a rural town,” Harris said. “If you get rid of Friday night lights, you’ve got a problem.”


This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Special Education Webinar
Big Goals, Small Start: Building MTSS to Scale
MTSS is a powerful framework for supporting student success, but implementation can be challenging. Learn from districts about their MTSS success stories and challenges.
Content provided by Panorama Education
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Recruitment & Retention Webinar
Exploring Staff Shortage Impact on Education
Learn about the impact of staff shortages, changing roles of educators, and how technology supports teachers & students.
Content provided by Promethean
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Assessment Webinar
Improving Outcomes on State Assessments with Data-Driven Strategies
State testing is around the corner! Join us as we discuss how teachers can use formative data to drive improved outcomes on state assessments.
Content provided by Instructure

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

School Choice & Charters Opinion A Charter Academy Delivering a ‘Classical’ Education Grows in Popularity
At its core, Great Hearts Academy seeks to foster virtuous human beings, explains the schools' CEO.
5 min read
Image shows a multi-tailed arrow hitting the bullseye of a target.
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty
School Choice & Charters A Proposed Catholic Charter School Is New Test for Religion and Public Education
With a favorable state attorney general's opinion in hand, Catholic officials are set to ask for approval of the first religious charter.
10 min read
Oklahoma Attorney General John O'Connor speaks during a bill signing ceremony for a bill making it a felony to perform an abortion, punishable by up to 10 years in prison, Tuesday, April 12, 2022, in Oklahoma City.
Then-Oklahoma Attorney General John M. O'Connor, shown last year in Oklahoma City, issued an advisory opinion last December that bolstered the prospects of charter schools sponsored by religious institutions.
Sue Ogrocki/AP
School Choice & Charters Opinion How Are Charter Schools Faring in Our Polarized Political Era?
There are several distinct and passionate school communities that reside under the charter school banner. Can they work alongside another?
6 min read
Image shows a multi-tailed arrow hitting the bullseye of a target.
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty
School Choice & Charters What to Know About a Neo-Nazi Home-School Scandal
Three things to know about how the incident connects to broader public education debates.
6 min read
Tight crop of hands typing on a laptop overlaid with a window that includes a video play button and red progress bar.
iStock/Getty Images Plus