Federal

Mapping Analysis Finds Interdistrict-Choice Options to Be Limited

August 26, 2008 3 min read

The use of interdistrict-choice programs is unlikely to increase most students’ educational opportunities significantly, a new report concludes, despite recent attention to the idea as a means of reducing economic and racial segregation and giving students in low-performing public schools a chance to find a better school.

“Only a limited number of students in a limited number of locations are likely to benefit from interdistrict choice—and even then, only if carefully crafted policies succeed where many past programs have failed,” says the report, issued this week by Education Sector, a Washington think tank that supports public school choice.

The study analyzes performance data and public school locations in California, Florida, and Texas, three of the most populous states. Using Geographic Information Systems mapping technology, it estimates the driving time from lower-performing schools to significantly higher-performing schools in the same geographic area.

Factors such as long distances to higher-achieving schools and limited capacity in those schools can severely constrain students’ ability to take advantage of interdistrict choice, the report concludes. Even under the best-designed interdistrict-choice programs, it says, 80 percent to 90 percent of students would remain in the same low-performing schools.

Some choice advocates have called for changes to the federal No Child Left Behind Act to make it easier for students in low-performing public schools to transfer across district lines to higher-performing ones.

Richard D. Kahlenberg, a senior fellow at the Century Foundation, a New York City-based nonprofit public-policy-research institution, argues that the new report is “fatally flawed” because it assumes that higher-performing schools would increase capacity at most by 10 percent.

“The whole report is premised on this assumption about capacity,” said Mr. Kahlenberg, who has written in favor of interdistrict-choice programs and is a nonresident fellow at Education Sector. “I don’t have the ability to tell you the right number is 10 percent or 5 percent or 30 percent, but neither does Education Sector.”

Uncertainty on Capacity

But Erin M. Dillon, the report’s author and a policy analyst at the think tank, argues that the 10 percent figure, while not scientifically based, was reasonable.

“If we’re looking to do this on a large scale, what can we expect schools to handle?” she said. “We felt like 10 percent was a realistic number.”

Education Sector also assumed a top driving time of 20 minutes to other schools. And it assumed that the choice option would be limited to students in the bottom 40 percent of schools, based on test data, and that those students would be permitted to transfer to other schools with substantially better performance outcomes.

Using those criteria, across California, about 7 percent of students at schools serving grade 3 could transfer to higher-performing schools when choice was limited to schools within the students’ home district. That climbs to nearly 12 percent when choice was expanded to include schools in other districts.

At grade 7, intradistrict choice in California was available for just 4 percent of students within the same district, and rose to 9 percent with interdistrict choice.

In Texas, the report found suburban students to be most likely to benefit from interdistrict choice.

Across states, Ms. Dillon said, extending the driving time to one hour generally had little impact.

“If one student can travel an hour, then all students can travel an hour,” she said, “so it actually doesn’t tend to change the numbers too much.”

The report highlights a few places, such as Plano, Texas, where interdistrict choice may be especially promising based on the proximity of low- and high-performing schools and available capacity.

The report offers proposals to help make interdistrict choice more viable, such as providing free transportation and creating financial incentives for schools to accept students.

Dianne M. Piché, the executive director of the Citizens Commission on Civil Rights, a Washington-based advocacy group, says the report is beneficial in beginning to look at maps and performance data to better gauge alternatives for students.

“It’s an imperfect picture,” she said, “but it’s the beginning of a picture of the landscape of choice possibilities.”

A version of this article appeared in the August 27, 2008 edition of Education Week as Mapping Analysis Finds Interdistrict-Choice Options to Be Limited

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Well-Being Webinar
Measuring & Supporting Student Well-Being: A Researcher and District Leader Roundtable
Students’ social-emotional well-being matters. The positive and negative emotions students feel are essential characteristics of their psychology, indicators of their well-being, and mediators of their success in school and life. Supportive relationships with peers, school
Content provided by Panorama Education
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
Making Digital Literacy a Priority: An Administrator’s Perspective
Join us as we delve into the efforts of our panelists and their initiatives to make digital skills a “must have” for their district. We’ll discuss with district leadership how they have kept digital literacy
Content provided by Learning.com
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
How Schools Can Implement Safe In-Person Learning
In order for in-person schooling to resume, it will be necessary to instill a sense of confidence that it is safe to return. BD is hosting a virtual panel discussing the benefits of asymptomatic screening
Content provided by BD

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Federal Miguel Cardona: Schools Must Work to Win Trust of Families of Color as They Reopen
As Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona announced new school reopening resources, he encouraged a focus on equity and student engagement.
4 min read
Education Secretary nominee Miguel Cardona testifies before the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions committee during his confirmation hearing Feb. 3, 2021.
Now-U.S. Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona testifies before the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions committee during his confirmation hearing in February.
Susan Walsh/AP
Federal CDC: Nearly 80 Percent of K-12, Child-Care Workers Have Had at Least One COVID-19 Shot
About four out of five teachers, school staffers, and child-care workers had first COVID-19 vaccine doses by the end of March, CDC says.
2 min read
John Battle High School teacher Jennifer Daniel receives her COVID-19 vaccine on Jan. 11, 2021. Teachers received their first vaccine during an all-day event at the Virginia Highlands Higher Education Center in Abingdon, Va.
John Battle High School teacher Jennifer Daniel receives her COVID-19 vaccine on Jan. 11at the Virginia Highlands Higher Education Center in Abingdon, Va.
David Crigger/Bristol Herald Courier via AP
Federal Ed. Dept. to Review Title IX Rules on Sexual Assault, Gender Equity, LGBTQ Rights
The review could reopen a Trump-era debate on sexual assault in schools, and it could spark legal discord over transgender student rights.
4 min read
Symbols of gender.
iStock/Getty
Federal Q&A EdWeek Q&A: Miguel Cardona Talks Summer Learning, Mental Health, and State Tests
In an interview after a school reopening summit, the education secretary also addressed teachers' union concerns about CDC guidance.
10 min read
Education Secretary Miguel Cardona speaks during a press briefing at the White House on March 17, 2021.
U.S. Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona speaks during a press briefing at the White House on March 17.
Andrew Harnik/AP