Equity & Diversity

Key Data on Charter Achievement Missing as Policy Questions Mount

By Debra Viadero — November 29, 2005 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The nation’s charter schools appear to enroll low-income students and students with disabilities in proportions similar to those in their surrounding districts, according to a report released last week. But it’s still not clear, the report adds, whether they provide a better education.

Numbering more than 3,300 in 40 states and the District of Columbia, charter schools are public schools that are allowed to operate free of most bureaucratic constraints in return for improved student achievement.

The report, produced by the Center on Reinventing Public Education, located at the University of Washington in Seattle, comes at a critical juncture for the nearly 15-year-old movement.

Read “Hopes, Fears, and Reality: A Balanced Look at American Charter Schools in 2005", available from the National Charter School Research Project.

With 448 charter schools opened in the 2004-05 school year, the movement grew faster last year than it has in any of the previous four years. But in at least 20 states, the largely start-up schools are bumping up against caps put in place to control their growth.

Scholars and charter school advocates are divided, according to the report, over whether future growth of the schools should come at the grassroots level or states should aim for critical masses of charters that could exert competitive pressure on regular school systems.

“It really does seem to me that charter schools have hit an important point in their development, and it’s time for a more sophisticated approach to research and policy,” said Robin J. Lake, the associate director of the Center on Reinventing Public Education. She co-edited the report with the center’s director, Paul T. Hill. The findings were set to be released on Nov. 21 at a forum held by the Urban Institute, a nonpartisan think tank based in Washington, D.C.

Aiming for Neutrality

Funded by a consortium of foundations convened by the Washington, D.C.-based Philanthropy Roundtable, the report is the first of what will be a series of annual reports and other studies tracking the charter movement. The series aims to sound a neutral voice in a debate that has grown more polarized in recent years—a task the first report largely accomplished, some experts said.

“I think what this report will do is reduce some of the simplistic views people have come to develop about charter schools,” said Jane Hannaway, the director of the Urban Institute Education Policy Center.

For example, on the issue of schools’ demographic makeup, the report notes that charters enroll higher percentages of low-income students and students from minority groups than do the regular public schools in the states where they operate.

Who Goes to Charter Schools?

Researchers compared the proportions of students who qualify for federally subsidized lunches in charter and district-run schools.

BRIC ARCHIVE

*Numbers represent percentage of students

SOURCE: National Charter School Research Project, 2005

Nationally, for instance, 58 percent of charter students are members of racial or ethnic minorities, compared with 41 percent for regular public schools in the same states. But, the report adds, that pattern reflects the fact that the largest proportion of charter schools—30.5 percent overall—are in large cities.

When compared with regular public schools in the same districts—a better comparison, the editors say—charters enroll nearly the same proportions of students in both categories. Getting the numbers right is important because critics often contend that charter schools “cream” the easiest-to-teach students from the regular public school system.

However, while the report goes beyond some previous studies to disentangle demographic questions, the authors need to go a step further, argued Gary J. Miron, an education professor from Western Michigan University in Kalamazoo who has also studied charter schools.

“In a lot of states, you have a number of schools that are almost exclusively minority or exclusively white,” said Mr. Miron, who reviewed the study. “Many of the states I’ve worked in have charter schools contributing to resegregation.”

Mr. Miron’s criticism highlights a recurring theme of the 83-page report: On most debates surrounding the charter movement, more and better research is still needed. For instance, many states lack data on the numbers of English-language learners in charter schools, which could further flesh out the demographic picture.

Data Elusive

Many states also lack the sophisticated student-tracking systems that might let experts determine whether students learn more in charter schools than they would otherwise, another big question in the policy debates that surround charter schools.

It’s still impossible to tell whether student achievement improves in charter schools, the report concludes, despite a spate of recent studies that have portrayed the academic progress of charter school students as either better or worse than that of their counterparts in regular public schools.

“For the beginning of a new area of scientific inquiry, the research is pretty good,” said Mr. Hill. “For making high-stakes policy decisions, it’s not good at all.”

Credible research into the subject is further complicated, he said, by the variation among states in the rules governing charter school operations, the numbers of charter schools allowed, and the kinds of entities that oversee them.

“ ‘Charter school’ is a label that we’ve assigned to 41 quite different phenomenon,” Mr. Hill said.

Events

Ed-Tech Policy Webinar Artificial Intelligence in Practice: Building a Roadmap for AI Use in Schools
AI in education: game-changer or classroom chaos? Join our webinar & learn how to navigate this evolving tech responsibly.
Education Webinar Developing and Executing Impactful Research Campaigns to Fuel Your Ed Marketing Strategy 
Develop impactful research campaigns to fuel your marketing. Join the EdWeek Research Center for a webinar with actionable take-aways for companies who sell to K-12 districts.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Privacy & Security Webinar
Navigating Cybersecurity: Securing District Documents and Data
Learn how K-12 districts are addressing the challenges of maintaining a secure tech environment, managing documents and data, automating critical processes, and doing it all with limited resources.
Content provided by Softdocs

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Equity & Diversity Should College Essays Touch on Race? Some Feel the Affirmative Action Ruling Leaves Them No Choice
After the end of affirmative action, the college essay is one of the few places where race can play a role in admissions decisions.
8 min read
Hillary Amofa listens to others member of the Lincoln Park High School step team after school on March 8, 2024, in Chicago. When she started writing her college essay, Amofa told the story she thought admissions offices wanted to hear. She wrote about being the daughter of immigrants from Ghana, about growing up in a small apartment in Chicago. She described hardship and struggle. Then she deleted it all. "I would just find myself kind of trauma-dumping," said the 18 year-old senior, "And I'm just like, this doesn't really say anything about me as a person."
Hillary Amofa listens to others member of the Lincoln Park High School step team after school on March 8, 2024, in Chicago. When she started writing her college essay, Amofa told the story she thought admissions offices wanted to hear. She wrote about being the daughter of immigrants from Ghana, about growing up in a small apartment in Chicago, and then deleted it all to avoid sounding like she was "trauma-dumping."
Charles Rex Arbogast/AP
Equity & Diversity Teacher, Students Sue Arkansas Over Ban on Critical Race Theory
A high school teacher and two students asked a federal judge to strike down the restrictions as unconstitutional.
2 min read
Arkansas Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders signs an education overhaul bill into law, March 8, 2023, at the state Capitol in Little Rock, Ark. On Monday, March 25, 2024, a high school teacher and two students sued Arkansas over the state's ban on critical race theory and “indoctrination” in public schools, asking a federal judge to strike down the restrictions as unconstitutional.
Arkansas Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders signs an education overhaul bill into law, March 8, 2023, at the state Capitol in Little Rock, Ark.
Andrew DeMillo/AP
Equity & Diversity Opinion What March Madness Can Teach Schools About Equity
What if we modeled equity in action in K-12 classrooms after the resources provided to college student-athletes? asks Bettina L. Love.
3 min read
A young student is celebrated like a pro athlete for earning an A+!
Chris Kindred for Education Week
Equity & Diversity Girls Are Falling in Love With Wrestling, the Nation's Fastest-Growing High School Sport
A surging number of states have sanctioned the sport, with bolstering from various groups.
6 min read
Benton's Callie Hess, left, battles Plum's Saphia Davis, right, during the first found of the PIAA High School Wrestling Championships in Hershey, Pa., on March 7, 2024. Girls’ wrestling has become the fastest-growing high school sport in the country.
Callie Hess, left, battles Saphia Davis, right, during the first round of the PIAA High School Wrestling Championships in Hershey, Pa., on March 7, 2024. Girls’ wrestling has become the fastest-growing high school sport in the country.
Matt Rourke/AP