Justices Weigh IQ Tests’ Role in Death-Penalty Cases

By Mark Walsh — March 03, 2014 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Intelligence testing came under scrutiny in the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday, not purely in the educational context, but in the unusual role it plays in some states in the imposition of the death penalty—or not.

The justices heard the appeal of Freddie Lee Hall, who has been on Florida’s death row since 1978 for the murder of a 21-year-old pregnant woman.

Hall, 68, has been considered “mentally retarded” by his family, teachers, and advocates throughout his life, and a court found him so at one point. In theory, he stood to benefit when the Supreme Court ruled in 2002, in Atkins v. Virginia, that the Eighth Amendment prohibits the execution of those with mental retardation.

The court held that the “diminished capacities” of people with mental retardation to process information, to learn from experience, to engage in logical reasoning, to control impulses, and to understand the reactions of others undermined the traditional justifications for the death penalty.

But the high court’s decision left much for the states to interpret. Florida adopted an IQ test score cutoff of 70 for someone to be considered mentally retarded, and the state’s highest court has interpreted state law as barring the consideration of a margin of error, known in the testing field as standard error of measurement, or SEM.

Hall has had scores on various IQ tests over the years ranging from a high of 80 to a low of 71.

In proceedings both before and after Atkins, lawyers for Hall reached back to his school years, when teachers classified him as “mentally retarded” and in need of a “special teacher,” which he never received. Hall was socially promoted for several years before he dropped out of high school.

Hall’s teachers noted that his “mental maturity is far below his chronological age,” that he was “extra slow in comprehension” and “slow in all of his work,” his lawyers argued in a Supreme Court brief.

The reliance on school records to try to establish Hall’s status was a use predicted at the time of the Atkins decision. In a 2002 story for Education Week, reporter Lisa Fine Goldstein reported that “criminal-defense lawyers now say that student special education records documenting the mental retardation diagnosis of defendants will prove to be key in such cases,” as would “testimony from teachers or from school psychologists.”

Hall’s effort to establish a claim of mental retardation under Atkins largely began and ended with his established IQ scores. A Florida court disregarded evidence that Hall had met other prongs for the clinical diagnosis of retardation and upheld his death sentence.

During the oral arguments in Hall v. Florida (Case No. 12-10882), the discussion ranged from standard deviations and measurement errors to composite scores and the uses of intelligence testing for remediation and even programs for the gifted.

Seth P. Waxman, Hall’s lawyer, argued that standard error of measurement would mean his client’s IQ scores fall within the definition of mental retardation, and he that should not be subject to execution.

“In this case, there were six experts who fully examined Mr. Hall” or supervised such an exam, Waxman said. “They were cognizant of the IQ test scores that he had received. And each one of them opined without hesitation that he had mental retardation, functional mental retardation.”

He noted that Florida uses IQ tests and the existence of mental retardation for such services as “educational remediation and vocational rehabilitation,” and the state uses standard errors of measurement in those instances.

In the death-penalty context, Waxman said, “If a state conditions the opportunity to demonstrate mental retardation on obtained IQ test scores, it cannot ignore the measurement error that is inherent in those scores that is a statistical feature of the test instrument itself.”

Allen Winsor, the solicitor general of Florida, argued that Hall’s teachers were not qualified to make a diagnosis of mental retardation, and that Hall was not administered an IQ test until he was 23.

Winsor told the justices that because Hall cannot meet the first prong of the modern diagnosis criteria for intellectual disability—the cutoff score for general intellectual functioning—the other two prongs do not matter. Those prongs are onset of the disability before age 18 and “adaptive functioning,” such as the ability to engage in logical reasoning and to learn from experience.

“All we’re stopping is the consideration of the other prongs when it’s clear that the first prong can’t be satisfied,” Winsor said.

“Florida has an interest in ensuring that the people who evade execution because of mental retardation are people who are, in fact, mentally retarded,” Winsor said. “And if we apply the rule that [Hall] has suggested, it would double the number of people who are eligible for the exemption.”

Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. asked Winsor whether the same principle would apply if a school set a strict cutoff score, say 130, for entry to a gifted education program, even when such a system excluded students within the standard error of measurement just below 130. “Would there be something wrong with their doing that?” Alito said.

Yes, said Winsor, “The decisionmaker who’s relying on an IQ test score, to take your example about someone in a school, they can set that as high or low as they want to, because they might want to be overinclusive, they might want to be particularly restrictive,” he said.

But the death-row context under Atkins is an “adversarial process,” Winsor said. “We have a burden of proof, a clear and convincing evidence burden of proof that’s not shared in the clinical setting.”

A decision in the case is expected by June.

A version of this news article first appeared in The School Law Blog.

Commenting has been disabled on effective Sept. 8. Please visit our FAQ section for more details. To get in touch with us visit our contact page, follow us on social media, or submit a Letter to the Editor.


This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Teaching Webinar
6 Key Trends in Teaching and Learning
As we enter the third school year affected by the pandemic—and a return to the classroom for many—we come better prepared, but questions remain. How will the last year impact teaching and learning this school
Content provided by Instructure
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
School & District Management Webinar
Ensuring Continuity of Learning: How to Prepare for the Next Disruption
Across the country, K-12 schools and districts are, again, considering how to ensure effective continuity of learning in the face of emerging COVID variants, politicized debates, and more. Learn from Alexandria City Public Schools superintendent
Content provided by Class
Teaching Profession Live Online Discussion What Have We Learned From Teachers During the Pandemic?
University of California, Santa Cruz, researcher Lora Bartlett and her colleagues spent months studying how the pandemic affected classroom teachers. We will discuss the takeaways from her research not only for teachers, but also for

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Education Schools Get the Brunt of Latest COVID Wave in South Carolina
In the past few weeks, South Carolina has set records for COVID-19 hospitalizations and new cases have approached peak levels of last winter.
4 min read
Two Camden Elementary School students in masks listen as South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster talks about steps the school is taking to fight COVID-19, Wednesday, Sept. 15, 2021, in Camden, S.C. McMaster has adamantly and repeatedly come out against requiring masks in schools even as the average number of daily COVID-19 cases in the state has risen since early June. (AP Photo/Jeffrey Collins)
Education More States Are Requiring Schools to Teach Native American History and Culture
Advocates say their efforts have gained some momentum with the nation’s reckoning over racial injustice since the killing of George Floyd.
3 min read
A dancer participates in an intertribal dance at Schemitzun on the Mashantucket Pequot Reservation in Mashantucket, Conn., Saturday, Aug. 28, 2021. Connecticut and a handful of other states have recently decided to mandate students be taught about Native American culture and history. (AP Photo/Jessica Hill)
Education Judge's Temporary Order Allows Iowa Schools to Mandate Masks
A federal judge ordered the state to immediately halt enforcement of a law that prevents school boards from ordering masks to be worn.
4 min read
Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds speaks to reporters following a news conference, Thursday, Aug. 19, 2021, in West Des Moines, Iowa. Reynolds lashed out at President Joe Biden Thursday after he ordered his education secretary to explore possible legal action against states that have blocked school mask mandates and other public health measures meant to protect students against COVID-19. Reynolds, a Republican, has signed a bill into law that prohibits school officials from requiring masks, raising concerns as delta variant virus cases climb across the state and schools resume classes soon. (AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall)
Education Hurricane Ida Deals New Blow to Louisiana Schools Struggling to Reopen
The opening of the school year offered teachers a chance to fully assess the pandemic's effects, only to have students forced out again.
8 min read
Six-year-old Mary-Louise Lacobon sits on a fallen tree beside the remnants of her family's home destroyed by Hurricane Ida, in Dulac, La., on Sept. 4, 2021. Louisiana students, who were back in class after a year and a half of COVID-19 disruptions kept many of them at home, are now missing school again after Hurricane Ida. A quarter-million public school students statewide have no school to report to, though top educators are promising a return is, at most, weeks away, not months.
Six-year-old Mary-Louise Lacobon sits on a fallen tree beside the remnants of her family's home destroyed by Hurricane Ida, in Dulac, La., on Sept. 4, 2021.
John Locher/AP