Equity & Diversity

Race-Based Assignment Challenged

By Caroline Hendrie — July 14, 1999 5 min read

White parents in Boston and black parents in Louisville, Ky., are turning to the federal courts this summer in pursuit of a similar goal: eliminating race as a factor in assigning students to their local schools.

Mirroring the national divisions over the value of integration and how it should be achieved, the two cases have rekindled deeply emotional debates that cut across racial lines. Both cases underscore the uncertainty and historic role reversals that have become increasingly common as the drive to desegregate American schools that began half a century ago winds down.

In Boston, the scene of some of the nation’s ugliest desegregation-related violence a generation ago, the school board was poised to vote this week on whether to scrap the use of race in student assignment.

The expected vote comes in response to a federal lawsuit brought by the families of four white children and a local advocacy group that favors neighborhood schools. They filed the suit on June 21--the 25th anniversary of a federal court ruling that touched off waves of busing-related turmoil in the city.

“The race-based student-assignment policy stands in the way in reform,” said Ann F. Walsh, the president of Boston’s Children First, the neighborhood-schools group spearheading the suit. “It’s also illegal.”

As of late last week, the Boston school committee had not issued a formal response to the lawsuit. But board members made clear their interest in settling the case, given what they perceive as slim odds of successfully defending the race-based assignment plan.

“Nobody wants a series of protracted court expenditures that will detract from our goal of improving quality across the system,” said Superintendent Thomas W. Payzant. “Recognizing the long odds against prevailing, the committee is leaning toward a modification of the policy.”

Curveball in Kentucky

In Louisville, meanwhile, a federal court fight is also crystallizing debate over the role of race in assigning students.

The battle was triggered by a suit filed in May of last year by six African-American parents seeking to end racial quotas that prevent hundreds of black students each year from attending a historically black high school in the city. District policy requires that African-Americans make up from 15 percent to 50 percent of each school’s enrollment, and Central High School has reached that upper limit. (“Suit Challenges Integration Plan in Louisville,” May 6, 1998.)

Last month, U.S. District Judge John G. Heyburn II threw all sides in the case a curveball when he ruled that some aspects of a 1975 decree ordering the Jefferson County school system to desegregate were still in force. Lawyers for the plaintiffs and for the 92,000-student district, which serves Louisville and its suburbs, had been operating under the belief that the decree had been dissolved in 1978, when another federal judge ended active supervision of the case.

The ruling is expected to result in a broad attack on the district’s entire student-assignment plan, rather than a challenge focused on admission to Central High.

The first step, though, is for the plaintiffs and the district to go head to head in court over the question of whether the 1975 decree should be fully lifted.

If the plaintiffs prevail in their effort to get the decree dissolved, Judge Heyburn noted in his June 10 decision, the district’s race-based assignment policies would be vulnerable to being found unconstitutional. The plaintiffs intend to make just such an argument.

As in Boston, much of the debate in Louisville centers on whether removing race-based enrollment quotas would trigger resegregation and a redistribution of resources unfavorable to mostly minority schools.

“We’re saying that we need to keep the order in place to avoid resegregation,” said Frank J. Mellen, the Jefferson County district’s outside counsel in the case.

The African-American plaintiffs, however, say they are far less concerned about racial balance than about minimizing the busing of black students and improving their academic achievement. “This situation is like medieval medicine,” said Carman W. Weathers, a member of Citizens for Equitable Assignment to School Environment, or cease, a group backing the suit. “It’s not working, but they say, ‘Let’s do more of it.’ ”

In Boston, the new suit is the latest salvo in a campaign by Children First and others to win a return to neighborhood-based schools. Mayor Thomas M. Menino, who appoints the school board, has recently voiced qualified support for that goal, but critics say he is moving too slowly.

School Leaders Chided

The plaintiffs contend it is unconstitutional for the system to assign students based on race. Beyond that, they say the district’s “controlled choice” assignment plan is stacked against white youngsters. Still, they firmly deny that resegregation is their ulterior motive. On the contrary, they argue that the schools are effectively segregated because white enrollment has dwindled so dramatically to less than 15 percent.

“The schools are not diverse because of this controlled-choice program,” said Patrice A. Gattozzi, an officer of Boston’s Children First and a plaintiff in the suit.

Last week, an ad hoc group of Boston parents who support the race-based assignment plan urged Children First to drop its suit. The parents, who are mostly white but also include some blacks and Hispanics, argued that without racial-balancing efforts, schools would become more inequitable.

Calling school leaders “weak and ineffective” for failing to stand up for a race-conscious assignment plan, Steven A. Backman a spokesman for the parents, said officials had “not done a good job of explaining their policies and defending them in a consistent way.”

But Superintendent Payzant pointed out that the system had vigorously but unsuccessfully defended itself against two lawsuits in recent years challenging race-conscious admissions policies at its most prestigious high school, Boston Latin School.

In February, the board reversed course and dropped plans to ask the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn an appellate ruling that ordered the district to adopt a race-blind admissions system at the school. Supporters of affirmative action had urged the district not to pursue the case, fearing that it could yield a decision invalidating race-conscious policies nationwide.

“I wouldn’t say that’s being timid or reserved in fighting for what we believe in,” Mr. Payzant said.

A version of this article appeared in the July 14, 1999 edition of Education Week as Race-Based Assignment Challenged


This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Student Well-Being Webinar
Measuring & Supporting Student Well-Being: A Researcher and District Leader Roundtable
Students’ social-emotional well-being matters. The positive and negative emotions students feel are essential characteristics of their psychology, indicators of their well-being, and mediators of their success in school and life. Supportive relationships with peers, school
Content provided by Panorama Education
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
School & District Management Webinar
Making Digital Literacy a Priority: An Administrator’s Perspective
Join us as we delve into the efforts of our panelists and their initiatives to make digital skills a “must have” for their district. We’ll discuss with district leadership how they have kept digital literacy
Content provided by Learning.com
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
School & District Management Webinar
How Schools Can Implement Safe In-Person Learning
In order for in-person schooling to resume, it will be necessary to instill a sense of confidence that it is safe to return. BD is hosting a virtual panel discussing the benefits of asymptomatic screening
Content provided by BD

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Equity & Diversity Opinion 'We All Have LGBTQ Students, Whether We Know It or Not'
Three educators provide suggestions to support LGBTQ students, including respecting pronouns and having LGBTQ authors in classroom libraries.
11 min read
Images shows colorful speech bubbles that say "Q," "&," and "A."
Equity & Diversity Opinion Strategies for Supporting LGBTQ Students
Three educators share ways to help LGBTQ students.
10 min read
Images shows colorful speech bubbles that say "Q," "&," and "A."
Equity & Diversity Opinion Trans Youth Are Under Attack. Educators Must Step Up
What can schools do in the face of the extreme hostility trans and gender-nonconforming young people now face across the country?
Harper B. Keenan & Z Nicolazzo
4 min read
A butterfly lands on balanced stones in front of tranquil waters and a sunset
Pict Rider/iStock/Getty images<br/>
Equity & Diversity Opinion When Does Educational Equity Become Educationally Unethical?
Equity stumbles into a truly gruesome place when educators are directed to shortchange students based on how they look or where they live.
3 min read
Image shows a multi-tailed arrow hitting the bullseye of a target.
DigitalVision Vectors/Getty