Apparently playing on the carpet and making up stories with little kids isn’t as “natural” as we are being told -- and may not be so much better for them. (Plus which, it’s boring -- admit it.) That’s the idea that this largely-ignored Boston Globe article from a couple of weeks ago raises (Leave those kids alone) -- along with questions about the idea that schools and other agencies should try and teach low-income and minority families to play with their children the way that many affluent, white families currently do. “The proselytizing on behalf of playful middle-class approaches vexes many anthropologists,” according to the article. This apparently includes Paul Tough‘s article on the differences between low-income and middle-income parents, which may according to the article have over-stated the deficits of low-income parents when it comes to stimulating their children’s development. There are also lots of implications for the universal preschool crowd (Clinton et al), whose programs often include a hefty dose of parenting instruction.
The opinions expressed in This Week In Education are strictly those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Editorial Projects in Education, or any of its publications.