Education

Thomas: Establishment Clause Jurisprudence ‘In Shambles’

By Mark Walsh — October 31, 2011 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Justice Clarence Thomas on Monday said that the U.S. Supreme Court’s establishment-clause jurisprudence is “in shambles.”

Citing divergent lower-court opinions on the display of crosses, the Ten Commandments, and other religious messages in courthouses, city halls, and public schools, Thomas said “our jurisprudence has confounded the lower courts and rendered the constitutionality of displays of religious imagery on government property anyone’s guess.”

“Even if the court does not share my view that the establishment clause restrains only the federal government, and that, even if incorporated [i.e., applied to the states], the clause only prohibits actual legal coercion, the court should be deeply troubled by what its establishment clause jurisprudence has wrought,” Thomas said in a lone dissent from the court’s denial of certiorari in Utah Highway Patrol Association v. American Atheists Inc. (Case No. 10-1276).

The Supreme Court on Oct. 31 refused to hear the case involving white crosses placed on or near spots where members of the Utah Highway Patrol were killed while on duty. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit, in Denver, ruled last year that although the crosses were placed by a private group, their location predominantly on public property conveyed a message that the state of Utah endorsed Christianity.

In his 19-page dissent, Thomas referred to a number of school cases that, in his view, reflect confusion or inconsistent application by lower courts of the Supreme Court’s rulings under the First Amendment’s prohibition against government establishment of religion.

He cited a 2005 decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit, in Richmond, Va., that upheld a Virginia law mandating the recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance in public schools. That court applied Van Orden v. Perry, a 2005 Supreme Court decision about public displays of the Ten Commandments. Thomas used the 4th Circuit reference to rebut the assertion of the group of atheists who challenged the Utah crosses that the high court’s Ten Commandments cases have not been applied to other areas of religious speech in the public square.

Thomas also cited a 2006 case which involved a challenge to the display of a menorah in the New York City public schools. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit, in New York City, upheld a school district policy allowing the display of a menorah along with the Islamic star and crescent, the Kwanzaa kinara, the Hebrew dreidl, and a Christmas tree, but prohibiting a Christian creche.

Referring to conflicting opinions by other lower courts, Thomas said that the message of the high court’s rulings is that “a menorah displayed on government property violates the establishment clause, except when it doesn’t.”

Thomas also cited a 2008 decision by the 10th Circuit court that upheld a mural depicting crosses in a public elementary school in Las Cruces, N.M.

Referring to these decisions and numerous others by the lower courts on religious displays, Thomas said, “One might be forgiven for failing to discern a workable principle that explains these wildly divergent outcomes.”

Appropriately for an opinion issued on Halloween, Thomas also cited with approval a famous description by Justice Antonin Scalia of the high court’s much-maligned Lemon test. Under that test, from the 1973 education case of Lemon v. Kurtzman, a government action that aids religion passes constitutional muster if it has a secular legislative purpose, it neither advances nor inhibits religion, and does not foster an excessive entanglement with religion.

In a concurring opinion in a 1993 school case, Lamb’s Chapel v. Center Moriches Union Free School District, Scalia mocked the Lemon test.

“Like some ghoul in a late-night horror movie that repeatedly sits up in its grave and shuffles abroad after being repeatedly killed and buried, Lemon stalks our Establishment Clause jurisprudence once again, frightening the little children and school attorneys” of the Center Moriches school district, Scalia said in Lamb’s Chapel. He said the Lemon test was essentially being ignored by the court, and that “no fewer than five of the currently sitting justices have, in their own opinions, personally driven pencils through the creature’s heart.”

In a footnote to the main opinion in that case, Justice Byron R. White had a retort for Scalia. “While we are somewhat diverted by Justice Scalia’s evening at the cinema, we return to the reality that there is a proper way to inter an established decision, and Lemon, however frightening it might be to some, has not been overruled,” Justice White said.

Thomas concludes his opinion in the Utah crosses case by arguing that confusion over the legality of public displays of religion prompts government officials and “everyday people” to choose a “safer course” of purging “from the public sphere all that in any way partakes of the religious,” which the establishment clause does not compel.

A version of this news article first appeared in The School Law Blog.

Events

Classroom Technology Webinar How Pandemic Tech Is (and Is Not) Transforming K-12 Schools
The COVID-19 pandemic—and the resulting rise in virtual learning and big investments in digital learning tools— helped educators propel their technology skills to the next level. Teachers have become more adept at using learning management
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Well-Being Webinar
Building Teacher Capacity for Social-Emotional Learning
Set goals that support adult well-being and social-emotional learning: register today!


Content provided by Panorama
Jobs October 2021 Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and other jobs in K-12 education at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Education Gunman in 2018 Parkland School Massacre Pleads Guilty
A jury will decide whether Nikolas Cruz will be executed for one of the nation’s deadliest school shootings.
3 min read
Annika Dworet and her husband, Mitch Dworet, wipe away tears as their son's name is read aloud during Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooter Nikolas Cruz's guilty plea on all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of attempted murder in the 2018 shootings, at the Broward County Courthouse in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. on Wednesday, Oct. 20, 2021. The Dworet's son, Nicholas Dworet, 17, was killed in the massacre.
Annika Dworet and her husband, Mitch Dworet, wipe away tears as their son's name is read aloud during Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooter Nikolas Cruz's guilty plea on all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of attempted murder in the 2018 shootings, at the Broward County Courthouse in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. on Wednesday, Oct. 20, 2021. The Dworet's son, Nicholas Dworet, 17, was killed in the massacre.
Amy Beth Bennett/South Florida Sun Sentinel via AP
Education Briefly Stated: October 20, 2021
Here's a look at some recent Education Week articles you may have missed.
8 min read
Education Gunman in Parkland School Massacre to Plead Guilty
The gunman who killed 14 students and three staff members at a Florida high school will plead guilty to their murders, his attorneys said.
4 min read
Parkland school shooter Nikolas Cruz is sworn in before pleading guilty, Friday, Oct. 15, 2021, at the Broward County Courthouse in Fort Lauderdale, Fla., on all four criminal counts stemming from his attack on a Broward County jail guard in November 2018, Cruz's lawyers said Friday that he plans to plead guilty to the 2018 massacre at a Parkland high school.
Parkland school shooter Nikolas Cruz is sworn in before pleading guilty, Friday, Oct. 15, 2021, at the Broward County Courthouse in Fort Lauderdale, Fla., on all four criminal counts stemming from his attack on a Broward County jail guard in November 2018, Cruz's lawyers said Friday that he plans to plead guilty to the 2018 massacre at a Parkland high school.
Amy Beth Bennett/South Florida Sun Sentinel via AP
Education California Makes Ethnic Studies a High School Requirement
California is among the first in the nation to require students to take a course in ethnic studies to get a diploma starting in 2029-30.
4 min read
FILE - In this Jan. 22, 2020, file photo, Democratic Assembly members, from left, James Ramos, Chris Holden Jose Medina, and Rudy Salas, Jr., right, huddle during an Assembly session in Sacramento, Calif. Medina's bill to make ethnic studies a high school requirement was signed into law by California Gov. Gavin Newsom on Friday, Oct. 8, 2021. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli, File)