Education

Supreme Court to Weigh Whether Pension Rules Apply to Church Schools, Hospitals

By Mark Walsh — December 05, 2016 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

The U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to decide whether religious hospitals and schools must adhere to the federal law that regulates most private pension plans.

The justices on Dec. 2 granted appeals from three hospital organizations affiliated with churches, but its decision could also affect religious schools, day-care centers, and other religious affiliates.

One of the appeals says that it has been settled law for more than 30 years that the pension plans of qualifying church-affiliated organizations are exempt from the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, the federal law that governs employers that offer pensions to their workers.

The three federal agencies charged with interpreting ERISA—the Internal Revenue Service, Department of Labor, and the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation—have agreed that such plans qualify for ERISA’s “church plan” exemption, which Congress adopted to avoid excessive entanglement between the government and churches. Since 1983, the three federal agencies have issued numerous opinions reaffirming their view, says the appeal filed by Advocate Health Care Network, a hospital system affiliated with the Evangelical Lutheran Church and the United Church of Christ.

“Countless nonprofit religious hospitals, orphanages, schools, day-care centers, and old-age homes have structured their pension plans in reliance on these agencies’ views and on the until-now-unanimous lower court decisions confirming their exempt status,” says the appeal.

But three recent federal appeals court decisions have held that ERISA’s church plan exemption applies only if a church “established” the pension plan.

“It is hard to overstate the burden and havoc these ... decisions have created,” says the appeal in Advocate Health Care Network v. Stapleton (Case No. 16-74).

The decisions have prompted dozens of class-action lawsuits against religious organizations that have relied on the church plan exemption for decades, Advocate Health says. The lawsuits seek billions of dollars in retroactive liability for noncompliance with ERISA’s recordkeeping and other procedural requirements, from which church plans are exempt.

The case “affects hundreds, probably thousands, of nonprofit religious employers and millions of employees,” Advocate Health says.

The other appeals accepted by the court were from two Roman Catholic hospital groups. In the Advocate Health case as well as Saint Peter’s Healthcare System v. Kaplan (No. 16-86) and Dignity Health v. Rollins (No. 16-258), the health concerns sought review of rulings by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit, in Philadelphia, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit, in Chicago, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit, in San Francisco, that church plans exempted under ERISA must be established by churches.

The status quo was challenged in a series of class actions filed on behalf of various ex-workers and pension holders of the hospital organizations. The suits seek declarations that the challenged plans were not church plans, and seeking damages and civil penalties. The suits also alleged that some of the plans were underfunded.

In briefs filed in response to the appeals, the challengers to Advocate, Dignity, and Saint Peter’s hospital systems argue that “giant healthcare corporations [like those three] must provide ERISA-mandated minimum protection and insurance for their employees’ pension plans, just like [the church-affiliated companies’] competitors must do.”

It is not clear whether the law firms behind the class actions have targeted any religious schools in their recent lawsuits. But some religious rights advocates argue that the Supreme Court’s decision in the cases up for review could affect the ERISA exemption for religious schools nationwide.

“Synagogues, mosques, churches, and other houses of worship should not be forced to decide between ceasing to provide retirement benefits and subjecting themselves to extensive government regulation of their internal operations,” says a friend-of-the-court brief filed by the Alliance Defending Freedom, a religious rights group. “These same considerations apply to the agencies of churches, synagogues, mosques, and other houses of worship.”

The three cases, which were consolidated, will be argued sometime early next year, with a decision expected by late June.

A version of this news article first appeared in The School Law Blog.

Events

Jobs October 2021 Virtual Career Fair for Teachers and K-12 Staff
Find teaching jobs and other jobs in K-12 education at the EdWeek Top School Jobs virtual career fair.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Data Webinar
Using Integrated Analytics To Uncover Student Needs
Overwhelmed by data? Learn how an integrated approach to data analytics can help.

Content provided by Instructure
Professional Development Online Summit What's Next for Professional Development: An Overview for Principals
Join fellow educators and administrators in this discussion on professional development for principals and administrators.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Education 'Widespread' Racial Harassment Found at Utah School District
The federal probe found hundreds of documented uses of the N-word and other racial epithets, and harsher discipline for students of color.
1 min read
A CNG, compressed natural gas, school bus is shown at the Utah State Capitol, Monday, March 4, 2013, in Salt Lake City. After a winter with back-to back episodes of severe pollution in northern Utah, lawmakers and Utah Gov. Gary Herbert will discuss clean air legislation and call for government and businesses to convert to clean fuel vehicles.
Federal civil rights investigators found widespread racial harassment of Black and Asian American students in the Davis school district north of Salt Lake City, Utah.
Rick Bowmer/AP Photo
Education Tiny Wrists in Cuffs: How Police Use Force Against Children
An investigation finds children as young as 6 and a disproportionate amount of Black children have been handled forcibly by police officers.
15 min read
Jhaimarion, 10, reacts as he listens to his mother, Krystal Archie talking with an Associated Press reporter in Chicago on Sept. 23, 2021. Archie’s three children were present when police, on two occasions, just 11 weeks apart, kicked open her front door and tore through their home searching for drug suspects. She’d never heard of the people they were hunting. Her oldest child, Savannah was 14 at the time; her youngest, Jhaimarion, was seven. They were ordered to get down on the floor.
Jhaimarion, 10, reacts as he listens to his mother, Krystal Archie talking with an Associated Press reporter in Chicago on Sept. 23, 2021. Archie’s three children were present when police, on two occasions, just 11 weeks apart, kicked open her front door and tore through their home searching for drug suspects. She’d never heard of the people they were hunting. Her oldest child, Savannah was 14 at the time; her youngest, Jhaimarion, was seven. They were ordered to get down on the floor.
Nam Y. Huh/AP
Education Gunman in 2018 Parkland School Massacre Pleads Guilty
A jury will decide whether Nikolas Cruz will be executed for one of the nation’s deadliest school shootings.
3 min read
Annika Dworet and her husband, Mitch Dworet, wipe away tears as their son's name is read aloud during Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooter Nikolas Cruz's guilty plea on all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of attempted murder in the 2018 shootings, at the Broward County Courthouse in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. on Wednesday, Oct. 20, 2021. The Dworet's son, Nicholas Dworet, 17, was killed in the massacre.
Annika Dworet and her husband, Mitch Dworet, wipe away tears as their son's name is read aloud during Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooter Nikolas Cruz's guilty plea on all 17 counts of premeditated murder and 17 counts of attempted murder in the 2018 shootings, at the Broward County Courthouse in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. on Wednesday, Oct. 20, 2021. The Dworet's son, Nicholas Dworet, 17, was killed in the massacre.
Amy Beth Bennett/South Florida Sun Sentinel via AP
Education Briefly Stated: October 20, 2021
Here's a look at some recent Education Week articles you may have missed.
8 min read