Find your next job fast at the Jan. 28 Virtual Career Fair. Register now.
Education

Marshall: Kagan a ‘Knucklehead’ on School Case

By Mark Walsh — May 13, 2010 2 min read

U.S. Supreme Court nominee Elena Kagan has written that the one case that Justice Thurgood Marshall “cared about most” during the term she clerked for him was Kadrmas v. Dickinson Public Schools.

In that 1988 case, the question was whether a North Dakota school district violated the Constitution’s equal-protection guarantee by refusing to waive a bus fee for a child from an indigent family who lived 16 miles from school.

In their internal discussions over the case, Kagan told Justice Marshall that she thought it would be difficult for the court to rule for the family. “After all, I said, indigency was not a suspect class; education was not a fundamental right,” Kagan wrote in a 1993 tribute to Marshall in the Texas Law Review. The district should be upheld because it had a rational basis for charging all students the transportation fee, she told the justice.

To this, Justice Marshall responded that she was a “knucklehead,” an appellation he sometimes used with his clerks.

“To Justice Marshall, the notion that government would act to deprive poor children of an education -of an opportunity to improve their status and better their lives--was anathema,” Kagan wrote.

Five justices on the court voted to uphold the school district, with Justice Sandra Day O’Connor eventually writing a majority opinion that aligned with Kagan’s initial view of the case. Marshall assigned Kagan to write a draft dissent. But he returned several drafts to her because they failed to express the justice’s views “in a properly pungent tone,” as she put it in the tribute.

In his final, published dissent in Kadrmas, Justice Marshall said the majority showed “a callous indifference to the realities of life for the poor.”

“For the poor, education is often the only route by which to become full participants in our society, In allowing a State to burden the access of poor persons to an education, the Court denies equal opportunity and discourages hope. I do not believe the Equal Protection Clause countenances such a result. I therefore dissent,” Marshall wrote in the dissent, joined by Justice William J. Brennan Jr. (Justices John Paul Stevens and Harry A. Blackmun dissented separately.).

Kagan, in the Texas Law Review tribute, concluded that in Justice Marshall’s view, “constitutional interpretation demanded, above all else, one thing from the courts: it demanded that the courts show a special solicitude for the despised and disadvantaged. It was the role of the courts, in interpreting the Constitution, to protect the people who went unprotected by every other organ of government--to safeguard the interests of people who had no other champion.”

(Hat Tip to Charlie Savage in today’s New York Times, whose story on Kagan’s year clerking for Marshall leads with the anecdote from the Kadrmas case.)

A version of this news article first appeared in The School Law Blog.

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
Branding Matters. Learn From the Pros Why and How
Learn directly from the pros why K-12 branding and marketing matters, and how to do it effectively.
Content provided by EdWeek Top School Jobs
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
How to Make Learning More Interactive From Anywhere
Join experts from Samsung and Boxlight to learn how to make learning more interactive from anywhere.
Content provided by Samsung
Teaching Live Online Discussion A Seat at the Table With Education Week: How Educators Can Respond to a Post-Truth Era
How do educators break through the noise of disinformation to teach lessons grounded in objective truth? Join to find out.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Special Education Teachers
Lancaster, PA, US
Lancaster Lebanon IU 13
Speech Therapists
Lancaster, PA, US
Lancaster Lebanon IU 13
BASE Program Site Director
Thornton, CO, US
Adams 12 Five Star Schools
Director of Information Technology
Montpelier, Vermont
Washington Central UUSD

Read Next

Education Briefly Stated Briefly Stated: January 13, 2021
Here's a look at some recent Education Week articles you may have missed.
8 min read
Education Obituary In Memory of Michele Molnar, EdWeek Market Brief Writer and Editor
EdWeek Market Brief Associate Editor Michele Molnar, who was instrumental in launching the publication, succumbed to cancer.
5 min read
Education Briefly Stated Briefly Stated: December 9, 2020
Here's a look at some recent Education Week articles you may have missed.
8 min read
Education Briefly Stated Briefly Stated: Stories You May Have Missed
A collection of articles from the previous week that you may have missed.
8 min read