Federal

NCLB Testing Said to Give ‘Illusions of Progress’

By Scott J. Cech — September 22, 2008 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Harvard University researcher Daniel M. Koretz had some good news and some bad news today for policymakers looking ahead to the reauthorization of the federal No Child Left Behind Act: The nation’s K-12 students are now attending Lake Wobegon schools.

That is, he said, for reasons that are politically better but academically worse, rampantly inflated standardized test scores are giving the misbegotten impression that, as in the fictional town made famous by radio personality Garrison Keillor, all children are above average.

“We know that we are creating, in many cases, with our test-based accountability system, illusions of progress,” Mr. Koretz told a roomful of policymakers and educators at a panel discussion here hosted by the American Enterprise Institute, a Washington think tank.

Mr. Koretz, a professor of education at Harvard’s graduate school of education who has written a new book, Measuring Up: What Educational Testing Really Tells Us, added that under the No Child Left Behind law, widespread teaching to the test, strategic reallocation of teaching talent, and other means of gaming the high-stakes testing system have conspired to produce scores on state standardized tests that are substantially better than students’ mastery of the material.

“If you tell people that performance on that tested sample is what matters, that’s what they worry about, so you can get inappropriate responses in the classroom and inflated test scores,” he said, citing research in the 1990s on the state standardized test then in use in Kentucky, which was designed to measure similar aspects of proficiency as the National Assessment of Educational Progress, often called “the nation’s report card.”

Scores on both tests should have moved more or less in lock step, he said. But instead, 4th grade reading scores rose dramatically on the state test, which in many ways resembled an NCLB-test prototype, from 1992 to 1994, while sliding slightly on the NAEP over the same period.

“If you’re a parent in Kentucky, what you care about is whether your kids can read, not how well they can do on the state test,” Mr. Koretz said. “And the national assessment told us that in fact the gains in the state test were bogus.”

Obscuring or Illuminating?

Bella Rosenberg, an education consultant and a longtime special assistant to the American Federation of Teachers’ late president, Albert Shanker, echoed many of Mr. Koretz’s critiques.

“This is officially sanctioned malpractice—if we did this in health, in medical practice, we’d all be dead by now,” she said of the testing system under the NCLB law. “The fact is, we’re doing a great job of obscuring instead of illuminating achievement gaps.”

But fellow panelist Roberto Rodriguez, a senior education adviser to U.S. Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, D-Mass., the chairman of the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee who helped shepherd the NCLB law through Congress in 2001, cautioned against “throwing the baby out with the bath water.”

While a more effective accountability system “needs to be a goal, I would argue, of the upcoming reauthorization of the ESEA,” he said, referring to the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, which is now known as NCLB, “summative assessment is a critically important area of accountability.”

With regard to the tug-of-war between advocates of the current standards-based system and detractors who prefer a system that better reflects the curriculum, Mr. Rodriguez said, “I think we can have our cake and eat it too.”

Williamson M. Evers, the U.S. Department of Education’s assistant secretary for planning, evaluation, and policy development, who attended the panel discussion, suggested that any changes to the NCLB law should preserve its essence. “Some are proposing changes in accountability that remove consequences; this would make it accountability in name only,” Mr. Evers said in an e-mail. “Results should be comparable statewide, or parents, taxpayers, and teachers themselves can’t tell how students are doing.”

A version of this article appeared in the October 01, 2008 edition of Education Week as NCLB Testing Said to Give ‘Illusions of Progress’

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Families & the Community Webinar
Celebrate Family Engagement Day With Strategies That Work
Join National PTA and AASA to explore practical systems-wide family engagement strategies in celebration of National Family Engagement Day.
College & Workforce Readiness Webinar What Are the Fastest-Growing Career- and Work-Based Education Programs?
Join us to explore EdWeek Research Center survey data on which areas of CTE are expected to grow the fastest over the next 5 years.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Reading & Literacy Webinar
Prove What Works: How to Know Which Literacy Evidence to Trust
Learn how to evaluate literacy research, question claims, understand outcomes, and make more confident, evidence-based decisions.
Content provided by Lexia Learning

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Federal An Architect of the Ed. Dept.'s Dismantling Will Leave the Agency
Lindsey Burke wrote the Ed. Dept. section of Project 2025 before arriving at the agency last year.
3 min read
EL 20260717 EducationWeekAFT109
The Department of Education headquarters in Washington, D.C. on Friday, July 17, 2026. Lindsey Burke, an architect of the department's dismantling who serves as the agency's deputy chief of staff for policy and programs, is leaving the agency at the end of the month.
Eric Lee for Education Week
Federal Changes to Census Could Affect School Funding, Programs
Proposed changes could lead to an undercount, affecting data used for funding, grants, and enrollment projections, education groups warn.
•
3 min read
Evelyn Morales, 6, holds a sign during a news conference of the Tennessee Immigrant and Refugee Rights Coalition outside the state Capitol, Tuesday, March 19, 2024, in Nashville, Tenn. Members of the group came to the state Capitol to lobby legislators to vote against legislation that require local law-enforcement agencies to operate as if they have federal 287(g) agreements and a bill criminalizing transportation of undocumented immigrants.
Evelyn Morales, 6, holds a sign during a news conference of the Tennessee Immigrant and Refugee Rights Coalition outside the state Capitol on March 19, 2024, in Nashville, Tenn. A new Trump administration proposal for the U.S. Census could undercount refugee and immigration children, potentially throwing off counts that inform how federal education funding is disbursed.
George Walker IV/AP
Federal Top House Democrat Launches Bid to Undo Trump's Ed. Dept. Scramble
The legislation shows stalling the dismantling of the Education Department will be a Democratic priority.
4 min read
Director of Educational Opportunities Project at the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights David Hinojosa (right) talks with Ranking member of the Committee on Education and Workforce Rep. Bobby Scott, D-Va., following a hearing of the House Subcommittee on Higher Education & Workforce Development on Thursday, Sept., 28, 2023 in Washington. The Lawyers' Committee is a leader in the fight for access and racial justice in higher education.
Rep. Bobby Scott, D-Va., (left) speaks after a hearing of the House Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Development on Sept. 28, 2023, in Washington. Scott has introduced legislation that would return the office for civil rights to the U.S. Department of Education, after the Trump administration transferred it to the U.S. Department of Justice.
Kevin Wolf/AP via images for Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights
Federal What a Trump Admin. Review of Civil Rights Guidance May Mean for Schools
The Education and Justice departments say seven guidance documents "are no longer enforceable."
6 min read
A hat with the word 'VETO' on it sits on the Resolute Desk as President Donald Trump speaks after signing an executive order in the Oval Office of the White House Thursday, Nov. 5, 2026, in Washington.
A hat with the word "VETO" on it sits on the Resolute Desk as President Donald Trump speaks after signing an executive order in the Oval Office of the White House Thursday, Nov. 5, 2026, in Washington. The U.S. Department of Education under Trump has begun a review of civil rights guidance documents issued during the Obama and Biden administrations.
Alex Brandon/AP