Social Studies Opinion

Civics Education: Can We Teach Patriotism Without the Conformity?

New requirements are good—if we learn from past mistakes
By Anil Hurkadli — August 24, 2023 5 min read
Illustration of cutout figures and U.S. flags.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Attending school in the middle of a cornfield only intensified my childhood feelings of isolation as a gay, brown kid born to Indian immigrant parents. In every way that matters to a child, I felt alien.

My civics education in school exacerbated those feelings. It consisted primarily of rote daily recitations of the Pledge of Allegiance and a watered-down history of European immigration through Ellis Island. Stories like my family’s were noticeably absent, signaling to me that loyalty and conformity were my only choices to feel a sense of belonging.

When I entered the field of education, I was eager to understand the many ways schools shape our understanding of community and citizenship. I quickly learned that my personal experience was part of a broader history. Schools have long played a prominent—and often disturbing—role in defining what it looks like, sounds like, and feels like to be an American. I was reminded of this history when the legislature in my home state of Iowa recently instituted new civics learning and testing requirements for high school graduation.

Over the past several years, many states have taken steps to strengthen civics education requirements in public schools. The bipartisan support for improved civics education is unsurprising considering our country’s intensifying political polarization (and the fact that only 47 percent of Americans can name the country’s three branches of government).

Nonetheless, how we choose to implement these new requirements matters. By examining and learning from the history of civics education in the United States, we can avoid repeating our public education system’s most troubling past mistakes. And we can help today’s young people develop new ways to engage as citizens, safeguarding our democratic institutions from authoritarianism and contributing to a more resilient, freer society in the process.

Civics first emerged as a distinct academic discipline in response to America’s foreign policy exploits and significant demographic, political, and economic shifts in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. School officials at the time worried openly about the threats posed to the nation’s health and moral character if children of families deemed too “foreign” weren’t taught to outright reject their cultures and embrace loyalty, conformity, and “100 percent Americanism.” Government policy choices—ranging from California’s Japanese language school ban to loyalty oaths for New York City teachers to American Indian boarding schools—reflected these fears and left deep scars that remain with us today.

This shameful history serves as clear evidence that civics education in the United States has often had political aims. A substantive teaching of history—including how and why a formal civics curriculum first came to American public schools generations ago—must be part of any effective civics curriculum today.

Schools have long played a prominent—and often disturbing—role in defining what it looks like, sounds like, and feels like to be an American.

Historical accounting helps us practice what theologian and ethicist Donald Shriver called “honest patriotism,” or “loving a country enough to remember its misdeeds.” Honest patriotism invites us to comprehend and (when necessary) take responsibility for past and present suffering while also asking each of us to decide what is, today, worth celebrating about our democracy. With this framing, we can make new choices about how to foster in students the knowledge, skills, mindsets, and relationships that will help them contribute to a thriving democracy.

What does this look like in practice?

First, be skeptical about any civics curriculum that relies heavily on memorization or a tidy, whitewashed single story of our nation’s history. Both stifle curiosity about our complex country’s past and present, leaving less openness to explore the wide range of personal and ancestral experiences represented in most American classrooms today. There isn’t—and never was—one way to be an American, and our civics curriculum and pedagogy should reflect that.

In their recent evaluation of Massachusetts’ new civics curriculum, the Center for Information and Research on Civic Learning and Engagement (CIRCLE) at Tufts University found that an inquiry-based approach showed notable promise in improving student engagement and enjoyment.

Imagine if my middle school social studies teacher taught her prescribed lesson about European immigration through Ellis Island and then assigned students to map and share their own trajectory to Iowa, depending on each person’s ancestral identities. I would have been asked to interview my parents and discovered—decades earlier than I did in reality—about my paternal grandparents’ migration from a rural village to Mumbai in search of work, about the devastating impact that the partition of India had on my mother’s family, and how changing American immigration laws (partly a response to Cold War politics) permitted each of my parents to immigrate to this country in the 1960s.

A modern civics education should also emphasize individual reflective practice. Identity development is critical for young people to make a successful transition into adulthood, and national identity must be integrated alongside race, ethnicity, immigration status, gender identity, sexual orientation, religion, ability, and other differences that make a difference in the lives of Americans today.

See Also

conceptual illustration of people gathering to form the map of the continental United States of America
Social Studies Opinion I'm a State Election Chief. We Need to Do Something About Civics Education
Michael G. Adams, November 22, 2022
4 min read

Helping students understand themselves as complex people living in a complex world is a mindset necessary for any subject, but it will be particularly helpful in supporting their ability to understand exactly how their experiences relate to content covered in their civics courses.

Equipping civics teachers with inquiry-based learning strategies—mirroring what STEM (science, technology, engineering, math) and ELA teachers have increasingly done—may involve rethinking how we train and develop them. In the meantime, organizations like CIRCLE or the Right Question Institute—which provides practical techniques for teachers and students to ask more critical questions—offer research and tools that help classrooms become our new laboratories of democracy.

This fall, students will return to classrooms in several states where a new civics education requirement has been enacted. I imagine there will be another lonely Indian boy in a rural school who agonizes about how to reconcile his personal and ancestral identities with his national one. When he does, my hope is that his teacher welcomes that conversation and has the civics education curriculum and professional learning to foster his sense of belonging without incentivizing conformity.

We need that child to see the world as it is but also as he needs it to be, imagining himself not as an outsider—as I once did—but as an essential member of American society.

Related Tags:


School Climate & Safety K-12 Essentials Forum Strengthen Students’ Connections to School
Join this free event to learn how schools are creating the space for students to form strong bonds with each other and trusted adults.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Reading & Literacy Webinar
Creating Confident Readers: Why Differentiated Instruction is Equitable Instruction
Join us as we break down how differentiated instruction can advance your school’s literacy and equity goals.
Content provided by Lexia Learning
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
IT Infrastructure & Management Webinar
Future-Proofing Your School's Tech Ecosystem: Strategies for Asset Tracking, Sustainability, and Budget Optimization
Gain actionable insights into effective asset management, budget optimization, and sustainable IT practices.
Content provided by Follett Learning

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Social Studies What the Research Says Oral History Offers a Model for How Schools Can Introduce Students to Complex Topics
Community history projects like a curriculum in Memphis, Tenn. can help students grapple with issues like school segregation, experts say.
4 min read
A group photo picturing 12 of the Memphis 13.
A group photo of 12 of the Memphis 13 students.
Courtesy of the Memphis 13 Foundation
Social Studies How These Teachers Build Curriculum 'Beyond Black History'
A pilot to infuse Black history and culture in social studies is gaining ground in New York.
4 min read
Photograph of Dawn Brooks-DeCosta at Thurgood Marshall Academy Lower School in the Bronx.
Dawn Brooks Decosta, pictured on Oct. 2, 2020, is the deputy superintendent of the Harlem Community School District 5 in New York. Its 23 schools piloted units of a curriculum developed in collaboration between local educators and the Black Education Research Center at Columbia University Teachers College.
Kirsten Luce for Education Week
Social Studies Q&A Here's How AP African American Studies Helps Teachers 'Get Students to Think'
Ahenewa El-Amin in Kentucky is teaching the second year pilot of the College Board's new course set to officially launch this fall.
4 min read
Ahenewa El-Amin leads a conversation with students during her AP African American Studies class at Henry Clay High School in Lexington, Ky., on March 19, 2024.
Ahenewa El-Amin leads a conversation with students during her AP African American Studies class at Henry Clay High School in Lexington, Ky., on March 19, 2024.
Jaclyn Borowski/Education Week
Social Studies What Students Have to Say About AP African American Studies
Students at Henry Clay High School in Lexington, Ky., share their takeaways from the pilot course that officially launches this fall.
5 min read
Nia Henderson Louis asks a question during AP African American Studies class at Henry Clay High School in Lexington, Ky., on March 19, 2024.
Nia Henderson-Louis asks a question during AP African American Studies at Henry Clay High School in Lexington, Ky., on March 19.
Jaclyn Borowski/Education Week