Law & Courts

Court Case Involving AIDS Virus Could Affect Schools

By Mark Walsh — April 08, 1998 3 min read

The first U.S. Supreme Court case involving the virus that causes AIDS also gives the court its first opportunity to interpret the Americans with Disabilities Act.

The case holds potential implications for schools and their treatment of employees and students who are HIV-positive. It could also affect how people with other contagious conditions are treated under a variety of disability laws.

In the case argued before the court last week, the justices must decide whether and when a person who carries the human immunodeficiency virus but shows no symptoms of AIDS is considered disabled under the 1990 federal disability law.

In Bragdon v. Abbott (Case No. 97-156), the high court is considering the case of Sidney Abbott, a woman whose Bangor, Me., dentist refused to treat her for a cavity at his office after he learned she was HIV-positive. The dentist said he would need to treat her in a hospital, which would have made the procedure more expensive.

The woman filed a discrimination suit under the ADA and won rulings in the federal district and appellate courts. Those courts said that a person with HIV, regardless of whether he or she has acute symptoms of AIDS, has a physical impairment that affects a major life activity and thus makes the person disabled under the act.

The courts said reproduction is the major life activity affected by HIV-positive status.

‘Moral Decision’

Although the Bragdon case is the first to directly involve the AIDS virus, the justices were aware of the AIDS crisis in 1987 when they decided a case involving a Florida school district that had fired a teacher who suffered a relapse of tuberculosis.

In School Board of Nassau County v. Arline, the high court ruled that a person with a contagious disease such as tuberculosis may be considered disabled under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. Public schools are barred from discriminating against people with disabilities under both the Rehabilitation Act and the more recent ADA.

In the Arline case, the high court declined to reach a decision about whether the carrier of a contagious disease such as HIV who does not have its symptoms could be considered disabled under Section 504.

Since the ADA’s enactment, the Department of Justice has taken the view that HIV-positive status is automatically a physical impairment that qualifies as a disability.

During oral arguments on March 30, some justices were troubled about whether to accept that widely accepted proposition. Justice David H. Souter said an HIV-positive person might forgo sex and reproduction as a result of a “responsible moral decision” to prevent spreading the disease. But he was not convinced that it was a physical limitation that would qualify the person as disabled.

The case should be decided by early July.

Spec. Ed. Case

In a separate action, the justices rejected without comment last week an appeal from an Indiana family that had asked the court to decide whether the main federal special education law requires a school district to provide an instructional aide for a student enrolled at a private religious school.

The court has ruled that the U.S. Constitution does not bar a district from providing such an aide. But lower courts have generally interpreted the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act as not requiring the provision of an aide when parents voluntarily enroll a child eligible for special education services in a private school.

In its appeal in K.R.v. Anderson Community School Corp. (No. 97-960), the Indiana family argued that the issue remains ambiguous even after Congress reauthorized the IDEA last year.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit ruled last year that Congress made clear in the reauthorized IDEA that districts have no obligation to provide comparable services to disabled children in private schools when such children have been offered a free, appropriate public education. The justices declined to disturb that ruling.

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Professional Development Webinar
Building Leadership Excellence Through Instructional Coaching
Join this webinar for a discussion on instructional coaching and ways you can link your implement or build on your program.
Content provided by Whetstone Education/SchoolMint
Teaching Webinar Tips for Better Hybrid Learning: Ask the Experts What Works
Register and ask your questions about hybrid learning to our expert panel.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Families & the Community Webinar
Family Engagement for Student Success With Dr. Karen Mapp
Register for this free webinar to learn how to empower and engage families for student success featuring Karen L. Mapp.
Content provided by Panorama Education & PowerMyLearning

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Director PEAK Academy Hapeville campus
Hapeville, Georgia, United States
Camelot Education
Technology Product Manager
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States
Camelot Education
2021-2022 Teacher (Districtwide)
Dallas, TX, US
Dallas Independent School District
[2021-2022] Founding Middle School Academic Dean
New York, NY, US
DREAM Charter School

Read Next

Law & Courts Biden Administration, Education Groups Back School District in Student Online Speech Case
A Pennsylvania district and its allies argue that administrators need to be able to discipline students for threatening or bullying speech.
5 min read
supreme court SOC
Getty
Law & Courts Federal Appeals Court Upholds School's Removal of 4th Grader's Essay on LGBTQ Rights
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit backs a principal who said the essay was age-inappropriate for inclusion in a school booklet.
4 min read
Image shows a courtroom and gavel.
imaginima/E+
Law & Courts U.S. Supreme Court Is Asked to Take Up Harvard's Consideration of Race in Admissions
Lower courts rejected claims by Students for Fair Admissions that the Harvard policies discriminate against Asian-American applicants.
3 min read
Rowers paddle along the Charles River past the Harvard University campus in Cambridge, Mass. on March 7, 2017.
Rowers paddle along the Charles River past the Harvard University campus in Cambridge, Mass.
Charles Krupa/AP
Law & Courts Accused Texas School Shooter to Remain at State Hospital
Doctors say the student accused of fatally shooting 10 people at a Texas high school in 2018 remains incompetent to stand trial.
1 min read
Santa Fe High School freshman, Jai Gillard writes messages on each of the 10 crosses representing victims in front the school in Santa Fe, Texas on May 21, 2018.
Santa Fe High School freshman, Jai Gillard writes messages on each of the 10 crosses representing victims in front the school in Santa Fe, Texas on May 21, 2018.
Steve Gonzales/Houston Chronicle via AP