'They're Taking Our Kids': Teen Gun Violence Is Plaguing Cities Big and Small
The bullets sprayed through her front door and window, leaving perfectly cylindrical holes in the glass. They blasted clear across the nursery, where her 2-year-old daughter's toys were strewn on the carpet. They burrowed into the kitchen cabinetry—and hit her teenage son and daughter.
Amid their screams, "All I could think of was, 'I'm not losing another child,'" Williams recalled, tears spilling down her cheek.
Her 18-year-old stepson—William Rollins VI, known as Lil Bill—had been gunned down two years before in Wilmington, Del., another victim of the city’s plague of teens shooting teens. His shooter was 17.
Wilmington isn't Chicago or Los Angeles, Baltimore or Detroit. It is a city of less than 72,000 people known primarily as the birthplace of chemical giant DuPont and as a cozy home for big banks and Fortune 500 firms. But an Associated Press and USA TODAY Network analysis of Gun Violence Archive data—gathered from media reports and police press releases, and covering a 3½-year period through June of this year—reveals that Wilmington far and away leads the country in its rate of shootings among young people under 18.
"It's nonstop, just nonstop," said William Rollins V, father of the teenagers. "Around every turn, they're taking our kids."
Of the 10 cities with the highest rates of teen shootings, most had populations of less than 250,000 people. Among them were Savannah, Ga.; Trenton, N.J.; Syracuse, N.Y., Fort Myers, Fla.; and Richmond, Va. Chicago was the lone large-population city high on the list.
Poverty and a sense of hopelessness in the most violent neighborhoods is a common thread. Syracuse, a university town that once cranked out air conditioners and televisions, now has a poverty rate of 35 percent.
Others, like Savannah, are deeply divided. While its antebellum mansions, gnarled live oaks, and marble monuments to war heroes drew more than 13 million visitors last year, away from the picture-postcard oasis of Southern Charm the scenery here quickly shifts to decaying neighborhoods, abject poverty, and deadly violence.
Size may play a role. In tightly packed neighborhoods, insults and perceived insults ricochet like shots in an echo chamber. One shooting inevitably leads to speculation about who will be targeted next.
"The streets remember," said Mark Denney, a state prosecutor who is trying to end Wilmington's retaliatory warfare.
Social media accelerates the threats, and the danger. Teenagers whose brains are years from fully maturing are roaming the streets with a gun in one pocket and a smartphone in the other.
"A juvenile with a gun is a heck of a lot more dangerous than a 24- or 25-year-old with a gun," said James Durham, the acting U.S. attorney based in Savannah.
During a recent presentation, Chaz Mollins, the coordinator of violence prevention programs for Christiana Care Health System in Wilmington, showed a group of teens a map of the city studded with pushpins, each marking the location of a shooting: white for injuries, red for homicides.
The pins, clustered in a handful of high-poverty neighborhoods, showed the kind of pattern you might see in an outbreak of some infectious disease, like Zika or Ebola, Mollins said.
"So," he said, "we are in the midst of an epidemic."
The problem facing Wilmington and these other cities: How to stop the spread?
For Malik Walker, the best thing about turning 18 wasn't the birthday party he threw for himself at a local hotel. It's the fact that, as an adult, he can now legally buy a gun.
Malik was just 12 when he dodged his first shootout on Wilmington's notorious west side. At 15, he was kneeling on a sidewalk, calling an ambulance as he pressed his shirt against his best friend's bloody chest. The friend had been shot 13 times on the corner where Malik had just been standing.
Three years later, the tall, slender teenager with an easy smile still shudders at the thought that, had he not stopped into a store for a juice, he could have been lying there, too.
"I'm scared to even tie my shoe, because I don't know who might creep up behind me," Malik said as a police car's strobing red-and-blue lights illuminate the unfurnished room where he and several friends have gathered on a sticky, summer night. "It makes me want to take these two eyes and make two more, and put them in the back of my head."
For teens in the First State's largest city, this is life.
In Wilmington, data from the Gun Violence Archive show that roughly 3 out of every 1,000 adolescents are injured or killed annually from gun violence. That is almost twice the rate reported from Chicago and just over 9 times the national average as reported for 2015 by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The Associated Press and USA TODAY Network found that even among cities with high levels of gun violence, these are the few where the teen hazard rate stands out.
To examine the issue of youth gun violence, the reporters used data from the Gun Violence Archive to isolate incidents in which a minor age 12 to 17 was either killed or injured.
The incidents were aggregated at a city level and then measured against the population in that age group to derive a "hazard rate"—the percentage of minors ages 12 to 17 in the city injured or killed in gun violence each year.
The population figures for 12- to 17-year-olds were based on 2010 U.S. Census Bureau estimates for legally incorporated "Place" entities. The incident data from the Gun Violence Archive was collected through that organization's monitoring of media and police reports across the country.
GVA is a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization that catalogues incidents of gun crime across the United States. The data used in the analysis spans 3½ years, from the start of 2014 through June 30, 2017.
The AP and USA TODAY Network analysis found that with the exception of Chicago, the cities with the highest youth hazard rates were nearly all similar in size—with populations of 50,000 to 500,000, based on 2016 Census population estimates.
The analysis found there are a half-dozen cities with particularly high youth hazard rates: Wilmington, Del.; Chicago; Savannah, Ga.; Trenton, N.J.; New Orleans; and Syracuse, N.Y. Wilmington, in particular, had a youth hazard rate nearly double that of any other city.
Several other smaller and mid-sized cities also showed high levels of teenage gun violence, but the rates began to level out after the top six.
Smaller cities naturally show higher variation than larger cities, but these six municipalities had such outsize youth hazard rates compared to others that it was clear teenage gun violence was a problem.
The AP and USA TODAY Network analysis also tested the youth hazard rate against the adult hazard rate to make sure the youth rate was unusually high, instead of just being a result of GVA's data-collection quality in certain cities.
GVA employs a team of people to help maintain its database, but could miss incidents for a variety of reasons. Those could include lack of publicity or coverage of a crime, or police departments mistakenly categorizing gun-related crimes as other types of incidents.
In doing this test, reporters found that Wilmington was one of roughly a dozen cities in the U.S. with a high overall per-capita gun crime rate.
Despite that, Wilmington's hazard rate for 12- to 17-year olds was still 60 percent higher than its adult rate, indicating that teens, in particular, faced a specific threat of gun violence.
Among the other five cities whose youth hazard rate stuck out, all save for New Orleans had a much higher rate for teens than for adults. In New Orleans, the rates for the two groups were the same.
The news organizations sought to measure teenage gun violence in America's cities because it is something the federal government does not track on a regular and comprehensive basis.
Nearly a quarter of Wilmington's residents live below the poverty line. Eighty-six percent of the city's youth receive some form of state assistance.
Single-parent families live packed together in old-style housing projects or dilapidated brick row houses. Already separated from the more prosperous parts of town, Wilmington's poorer and largely black neighborhoods are divided physically by Interstate 95, which bisects the city, and by cliques that carve those neighborhoods into rival sections: Hilltop and West Center City; "The Hill" and "Down Bottom."
About 30 active street crews exist in Wilmington today, estimated David Kennedy, a national expert in criminology who has for years studied the city's crime problem. Prosecutors say these crews, made up of roughly 20 people per group, are responsible for most of Wilmington's crime.
A yearlong investigation by The News Journal, Gannett's Wilmington newspaper that is part of the USA TODAY Network, detailed a veritable war between two groups—Only My Brothers and Shoot to Kill. A News Journal analysis of court records, social media, and the newspaper's internal database found that a third of the shooting victims under age 21 during the first seven months of 2016 had links to the rivalry.
The feud began in January 2015 with the death of 16-year-old Jordan Ellerbe, gunned down while listening to music with friends on a front porch in the city's Hilltop neighborhood. The same home was targeted again two days later, leaving three mourners wounded.
The war escalated in the months that followed. One gang member would shoot at a rival; weeks later, fire would be returned. In May 2016, 15-year-old Brandon Wingo was shot and killed on his way home from school.
A month later, three alleged members of Shoot to Kill were charged with the popular basketball player's death. Between July and September of 2016, officials arrested 28 alleged OMB members on charges of gang participation, carrying concealed guns, robbery, and attempted assault. An additional teen was later charged as part of OMB, bringing the total to 29.
Wilmington's new police chief, Robert Tracy, says the city needs to do more of this—identifying those committing crimes and getting them off the street. It's a strategy employed in other cities.
"There's a small percentage of individuals that are going back and forth causing this violence in the city," Tracy, Chicago's former top crime strategist, said earlier this year during a vigil for a 6-year-old boy who had been shot. "And all the good people are tired of it, and they're outraged."
Unlike larger, more organized criminal enterprises such as the Crips, the Bloods, or the Mexican Mafia, feuds among teenage gangs in Wilmington don't revolve around drugs, or territory, or even money. It's about respect.
In the internet age, bad blood can spring up and spread instantly online with the double tap of a thumb on a smartphone screen or a hastily tapped-out Tweet. Teenagers in Wilmington don't sport gang colors or uniforms, but identify themselves with emojis and hashtags.
"Technology's evolution has made it easier for criminals to get guns," said Deputy Attorney General Joseph Grubb. "It also has made it easier for young people to get offended by something, causing them to go grab a gun and shoot up a block as opposed to, 'Meet me in the school yard and let's fist fight.'"
And every shooting opens up the possibility for another, as the thirst for retaliation creates a bloody game of back-and-forth: a life for a life for a life. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention research, young men under the age of 34 who have been shot in Wilmington are 11 times more likely to commit gun violence in their lifetimes.
Mayor Mike Purzycki said some of the blame can be laid on a "fractured education system" that sends children on buses to schools in rival neighborhoods. Many fathers are either in prison or have past convictions that make it difficult for them to find good jobs.
All of this leads to hopelessness and powerlessness, said the Rev. Derrick Johnson of the Joshua Harvest Church. "Pastor D," as he's known on the streets, understands that feeling, because he too has been there. Johnson was a 17-year-old drug dealer when he fatally shot a man. Thanks to a rehabilitative program, he was pardoned after serving 15 years.
At 59, Johnson's ministry is as much in the streets as it is in the pulpit.
One afternoon, Johnson strolled down the stairs of the William "Hicks" Anderson Community Center in the city's troubled West Center City neighborhood. A group of little girls, licking Popsicles, stood on the landing, leaning against the railing and peering down at the pastor. He reached into his pocket and handed each child a dollar bill.
"What you be doing when they be shooting around here?" he asked the children.
"Running home," said a girl with pigtails.
"You run?" the minister said, "you're supposed to duck."
"I learned that in school," another girl shouts. "I duck my head, somewhere where they won't find me."
On Nov. 3, 2015, Rayquan Briscoe was walking down Maryland Avenue for an appointment with his probation officer on a drug conviction. He heard gunshots. Briscoe tried to run, but his legs failed him: He'd been struck in the back, just to the right of his spinal column. He was paralyzed from the waist down. He was 17 years old.
"Bullets don't have no names," he said.
Although Briscoe said he's never carried a gun himself, guns have had an outsized impact on his young life.
Last year, Briscoe's father was shot to death. Rayquan's younger brother, Raymire, was just 14 when he was charged with murder in the May 2014 killing of a 29-year-old man; he pleaded guilty to manslaughter and was sentenced to 15 years in prison.
Despite all that, Briscoe said there are legitimate reasons for teens in Wilmington to arm themselves.
"Somebody after you with a gun, your only other option is to pick up a gun," he said. "If somebody, for instance, has a brother and they know that their brother's been shot or killed from a gun, then that's a legitimate reason for them to want to do something to somebody else, or carry a gun," he said. "That might be their only way of feeling better or dealing with life after that."
Unless and until guns are outlawed, Briscoe said, he doesn't see anything changing.
"It's the world," he said. "As long as killings keep going on, it's gonna be more killings. As long as more guns made, it's gonna be more guns."
Wilmington officials have desperately cast about for solutions—without success, at least so far.
In December 2013, City Council President Hanifa Shabazz asked the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to investigate. It would be the agency's first-ever inquiry into gun violence as a public health epidemic. The agency found that, between 2009 and 2014, 15 percent of the people arrested in Wilmington for a firearms crime were under the age of 18.
The CDC recommended that agencies share information such as school truancy records, child welfare reports, and emergency room visits to identify youth who need help earlier in life to avoid violence later. But after closing a $400 million budget gap through a combination of tax hikes and spending cuts, Gov. John Carney said the state doesn't have the money to execute the CDC's plan.
A CDC advisory council proposed linking four city schools with community health and social services in New Castle County. In May, the mayor announced a neighborhood stabilization program he hopes will revitalize the city's roughest neighborhoods by beefing up the police presence, cracking down on liquor stores and increasing trash pickup.
The community, meanwhile, is pressing forward on its own.
Derrick Reed, owner of His Image Barber Lounge near Wilmington's Little Italy, began holding sessions for teens at his shop on Monday evenings. He calls the program Born for Brothers.
"We're actively talking to these young guys when they get in the chair," said Joel Payne, one of the barbers. "We teach them about respect. We're teaching about morals. We teach them about values. We teach them about success."
Payne, now 31 and a father, speaks from personal experience: "I used to live that life."
He was just 12 when he stole his first gun—a chrome-plated, pearl-handled .380-caliber semi-automatic. At 16, he pistol-whipped a man during a home invasion. By 17, he'd graduated to shooter: He shot another boy in the leg during a robbery.
Payne was 11 when his father got back from a prison stint for drugs. His mother was working all the time to support him and his seven siblings. Missing meals, wearing his sisters' hand-me-down sneakers, watching the drug dealers flash their jewelry and cars. It all added up.
"When you grow up with a reality of rejection, and feeling alone, and nobody there to really like talk to and express your feelings, you look for other ways to express yourself," he said.
Latisha Jackson, too, speaks from personal experience. She organized 302 MAFIA (302 is Wilmington's area code; MAFIA stands for Mothers and Fathers In Action) to create a support system for those returning home from prison. But Jackson said it is also meant to awaken parents like her, who were "walking blind" while their children drifted toward violence.
With their father away in prison, Jackson worked two full-time jobs to provide for her boys, Jahlil and Na-Quan Lewis. She took them on vacations, got them involved in football and basketball. She forbade violent video games, never allowed so much as a squirt or BB gun in the home.
To no avail.
Jahlil was just 16 when he grabbed a pistol and set out with other OMB members to the house of a rival gang member. Police got wind of their plan, and Jahlil and three others were arrested en route to their intended target. Investigators later found images of Jahlil and Na-Quan brandishing guns on social media and in cellphone pictures.
Earlier this year, Jahlil pleaded guilty to felony charges of gang participation, possession of a firearm by a prohibited juvenile, carrying a concealed deadly weapon, and second-degree conspiracy for planning criminal acts with gang members. He was sentenced to two years in prison. Na-Quan, now 20, pleaded guilty in July to possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony and a probation violation on a 2014 robbery conviction. He was sentenced to three years, plus four years and 11 months for breaking probation.
Each time Jackson visits Jahlil, the routine is the same.
"I hold his hands and tell him how cold his fingers are," she said. "And then I look at him and say, 'I just cannot believe that my baby is in adult penitentiary.'"
William Rollins and Maria Williams believe the attack on their home can be traced back to the death of Lil Bill, in January 2015. In its aftermath, Rollins had received chilling text messages with photographs of his youngest son, just 11 at the time. "Should he be next?" the sender asked. Other threats in texts and on social media followed.
On July 21, John Brisco, aka "Bin Laden," was given two life sentences in Lil Bill's murder. So notorious is the Touch Money Crew gangster in the Hilltop neighborhood that "Osama City" was scrawled in Sharpie on the wall of a liquor store. "Love you, Osama," said another tag; and another, #LongliveOsama.
On July 26, the Rollins' home came under fire.
After the children were released from the hospital, the family left Wilmington. On a recent afternoon, 16-year-old Keshon and 18-year-old Kieshonna sat on a picnic bench beneath a shade tree. Kieshonna unwrapped the bandage from her knee to reveal an angry inch-wide gash just below her kneecap; Keshon's wounds had scabbed over.
The teenagers want to return to Wilmington, but their parents will have none of that world.
"The craziest thing about it is, these kids are accepting it," William Rollins said. "Like, they're accepting going to jail for life. They're accepting getting put in the grave. But they don't realize the effect that they do to everybody else around them."
To his wife, gun violence among teenagers has simply become part of everyday life in Wilmington: "Somebody taking somebody's child's life, over nothing."