|When two boys burned the high school in Cross Plains, Texas, the town was left asking why.|
Cross Plains, Texas
On Sunday, Dec. 7, 1997, all the clocks in Cross Plains High School stopped at 3:30 a.m. By that time, a fire at the school was roaring out of control. A nearby portable building that housed art classes was also ablaze. A few hours and more than $1.5 million in damages later, both structures were reduced to smoking shells. As temperatures within the main building soared to an estimated 2,000 degrees, 18-inch-thick steel beams in the roof sagged, and brick walls bowed.
Investigators say it could have been worse: If the fire had burned through the roof, the entire school might have been destroyed. As it was, the proud centerpiece of this small, nondescript West Texas town was badly damaged. "Nearly everybody in town went to this high school," says Ed Duncan, who was the town's police chief at the time of the blaze. "Their trophies were destroyed, their memorabilia. A lot of these adults here suffered a loss."
Later, when investigators poked through the remains of charred desks, melted computers, and blackened test papers, they found evidence of seven separate fires. The smell of gasoline lingered in the hallways, offices, and classrooms.
Within a day, two 16-year-old Cross Plains High students were arrested and charged in connection with the fire. Soon after, an 18-year-old who had graduated from the school only months before was arrested and accused of helping the two boys.
In this dusty crossroads town of 1,060, where the Texas highlands step down to meet the rolling plains, most residents already knew the story of the fire before it appeared in the local papers. And most already knew the two boys. They played for the Cross Plains football team, the Buffaloes, and in Texas, football is king.
Both boys quickly admitted their role in the fire, and each was sentenced in late March to up to five years in a maximum-security, lock-down facility. The 18-year-old has pleaded not guilty to arson charges and is still awaiting trial.
In a school year when tales of student violence in small-town America were all too common, the Cross Plains fire was nothing more than a disturbing footnote. Forty-two people were killed in school shootings in the 1997-98 school year, a few more than the average in recent years. But the nature of the crimes was shocking, as wholesome-looking boys took up high-powered weapons and calmly mowed down their classmates in the towns of Pearl, Miss.; West Paducah, Ky.; Jonesboro, Ark.; and Springfield, Ore. ("Officials Take No Chances After Killings," June 3, 1998.)
Still, what happened in Cross Plains illustrates a phenomenon nearly as alarming as the shootings. During the months that Americans were transfixed by the tales of students killing other students, there were nearly as many stories--if not more--of children setting fire to their schools. A few days before the two students were charged in the Cross Plains fire, a 12-year-old boy was arrested for his role in an elementary school fire in northeast Dallas. And about a month later, two cheerleaders at Norwood Middle School in Cincinnati piled up papers and mops that were being used as props for a play and started a fire in their school's ornate auditorium.
These arsons were by no means an aberration. More than half of all school fires are started intentionally, according to the U.S. Fire Administration, and they account for $50 million in damage to school property annually.
Roughly 95 percent of public and private schools carry fire-protection insurance, according to Jayna Neagle, a spokeswoman for the Insurance Information Institute in New York City.
The increased insurance rates that follow an arson are a large concern, according to a report by the National School Safety Center in Westlake Village, Calif. But the NSSC 's 1995 report on arson in schools also cites several nonfinancial problems related to fires; among them are lowered morale, loss of study and work time due to injuries or canceled classes, and negative publicity related to school safety.
Each year, on average, one person dies and 80 are injured in school fires. But statistics about deaths and damage to buildings don't tell the whole story. "There are probably many more school fires than we know about," says Paul Schwartzman, a mental-health counselor in Rochester, N.Y., and a leading expert in the study and treatment of juvenile fire-setters. "Schools protect themselves. Here in upstate New York, when we started to do more intervention, it took a whole lot of trust-building before we could get administrators to call in the fire department when there was a problem."
And while arson may not take as many lives each year as school shootings, it inflicts the same kind of wounds on the psyche of a school's staff and student body. "You can't underestimate the impact of an arson," says Ronald D. Stephens, the executive director of the NSSC. "You talk with the teachers afterward, and they feel personally invaded and threatened."
It is difficult to determine who sets school fires. Arsons of any type are rarely solved--only 15 percent of arson investigations end in an arrest, according to federal statistics. And in many school fires, the arsonists are never caught. In Virginia Beach, Va., for example, authorities still have made no arrest in a September 1995 blaze that caused $7 million in damage to Princess Anne High School.
Still, some fire investigators say it's clear that students are responsible for a large percentage of school fires, big and small. Tom Minnich, the chief of the Fire Management Program at the USFA, says, "I know just from talking to investigators from around the country that many school fires are set by students themselves."
Schwartzman, one of the leaders of a Rochester program to prevent children from starting fires, says school arson appears to attract older students. Residential fires are often set by children younger than 10 who experiment with lighters or matches found in the home. As children grow older and become more mobile, however, some start fires in vacant buildings, dumpsters, garages, fields, and schools.
And far more boys than girls set fires. According to Schwartzman, research suggests that boys are responsible for 85 percent of juvenile arsons. "We see boys much more involved in conduct disorders and other aggressive behavior," he says. "Some of that is genetic, and some is socialization."
There's no one reason why young fire-setters target schools. Sometimes, youngsters set a fire as a prank or as a way to get out of a final exam. Other times, they are responding to peer pressure or simply seeking attention. "You're in the boys' bathroom, you've got a lighter in your pocket, and you're going to make a statement," Schwartzman says.
Revenge is another motive. For students who have had a run-in with a principal or teacher, starting a blaze is a particularly satisfying retaliation, says Judy Coolidge, the program coordinator for Oregon's Juvenile Fire-Setter Intervention Program. "A fire totally disrupts the routine of the schools, which is what administrators want to avoid. It's the same in schools where there are a lot of false alarms. They have the same effect."
Says Wolfgang Halbig, the director of security for schools in Seminole County, Fla., ''You've got to keep an eye on the ones who are expelled or suspended."
But safety officials and fire-prevention experts also suspect that some fires are set by children who are emotional powder kegs. "In the old days, we never thought that kids would come onto the school campus with the intent to burn it and destroy it," says Halbig, a former principal and police officer. "Kids are angry today; they're frustrated."
"In the old days, we never thought that kids would come onto the
school campus with the intent to burn it and destroy it. Kids are
angry today; they're frustrated."
Schwartzman hasn't studied school arsonists specifically, but he says chronic neglect or abuse is one of the best predictors of a child who will set fires. "There's about a fivefold increase in repeat fires in families where there's a documented history of neglect or physical or sexual abuse," he notes. Or there may be other problems at home, including a parent's alcoholism or mental illness, divorce, or criminal involvement.
Through arson, Schwartzman says, such troubled children "learn the power of fire."
Sometimes, such as in the case of the Cincinnati cheerleaders, there doesn't appear to be an explanation. On Jan. 30, at Norwood Middle School, in the heart of the relatively small, middle-income Norwood City school district in southern Ohio, a fire was started in the auditorium while the school was still brimming with extracurricular activities. It nearly burned the 86-year-old building to the ground. "The firemen told us that if the fire had gone another 10 to 15 minutes undetected, we would have lost the whole building," Principal Gerry Addison says.
Investigators ultimately focused their investigation on two girls, 12 and 13, whose eyewitness accounts of the blaze were inconsistent. "They weren't skilled at lying," the principal says. "It didn't take long."
Addison was stunned to learn the two girls were responsible. They were cheerleaders and good students who had never been in trouble before. To this day, Addison says he has no idea why the fire was set. "The thing that shocked me was that they didn't know why they did it," he says.
According to a story in The Kentucky Post, a newspaper in the border city of Covington, Ky., the 13-year-old offered a tearful apology in court: "I'm very sorry and ashamed. I never intended the fire to get that big or spread. If you let me go, I promise you'll never see me here again."
Both girls were expelled and placed under house arrest for the duration of the school year. A psychological evaluation suggested they posed no future threat. One girl left the school, but the other returned this year. Addison is hoping for the best. "She's got her friends," he says. "I see her laughing. She seems fine."
Explanations also elude educators at the Community School of Westwood, a private high school for learning-disabled students in New Jersey's Bergen County. That school was destroyed by a blaze that swept through the building on March 12, displacing 132 students. No one was hurt.
Eventually, a 17-year-old student admitted to the crime. School co-director Toby Braunstein describes the boy as an average student, with no history of difficulties or behavior problems at school. "This really wasn't a case of a child who had any arson background," he says. "It was simply a case of very poor judgment and impulsivity. He was very remorseful. This was not something he intended to do."
Cross Plains is 40 miles south of Abilene, about an hour's drive down Route 36, a narrow, two-lane country blacktop. The road cuts straight through the parched, flat landscape known as Big Country. Every few miles or so, gnarled, scrub-covered hillocks rise suddenly from the earth. Past ranches, peanut farms, and vast hay fields, there is Turkey Creek and the town that has grown up along its banks.
A flashing traffic light marks the town's main intersection, where Route 36 meets Route 206. There's a Subway sandwich franchise nearby, but most of the businesses are home-grown, like the Stop & Go Pit Barbecue, Collum's Steakhouse, and Wild Texas Taxidermy. In one block of Route 206, the town's main street, a well-tended, 8,500-volume library occupies a storefront alongside a pool hall. Small, generally conservative Christian churches are plentiful.
Cross Plains High is on Route 206, a few blocks from the main intersection. Last Dec. 6, trouble began brewing north of town, at a keg party on a ranch in Eastland County, according to then-Police Chief Ed Duncan. About 50 students were at the party, including about 30 Cross Plains athletes and the two boys who eventually would claim responsibility for the fire. At some point during the party, the two boys left, hopped into a pickup truck, and drove to town. The other teenagers at the party say they didn't know what the boys were planning, Duncan says.
|Whatever theories can be constructed as to why kids set fire to schools, there's just no explaining it sometimes.|
Once at the school, the boys smashed a rear window with a chunk of concrete drainage pipe. Inside, Duncan says, they poured copier fluid on a desk and set it on fire.
What happened next is not clear; Duncan says the boys have never given a full accounting of their actions that night. But it appears that after they started a few fires in the school, the boys left and met up with Corey Lee Switzer, a former Cross Plains football player. Switzer had attended a bachelor party in Abilene earlier in the evening and was driving around town when he ran into the two students. Switzer and the boys then went to a nearby Conoco gas station, where they bought gasoline, Duncan says. Switzer has steadfastly maintained his innocence, saying he did not know what the two boys planned to do with the fuel.
Afterward, Switzer and the boys went their separate ways, according to Duncan, and the boys re-entered the school. One or the other--and possibly both--splashed gasoline over desks, floors, walls, the trophy case, and school records and set fire to it all. Along the way, Duncan says, they broke into vending machines and yanked the alarm system out of the wall.
Upon leaving the building, they broke into the nearby portable building and set it ablaze, too, according to Duncan. About 4 a.m., as the town slept, a woman who delivers newspapers saw smoke rising from the portable building and called the fire department.
"To have gone through and done what they did and splash as much gasoline as they did, it looks like they'd have to have been in there at least an hour," says Don Turk, the deputy state fire marshal. "I came up with seven separate fires.
"Some of the areas had good starts, and some of them didn't. The superintendent's office got to going real good. The fire in the principal's office never did get going. They'd shut the doors, shutting off oxygen to it. The fires in the lockers never did start. Everything else was locked up. Had everything not been locked up, they would have put it on the ground. There would have been nothing the firefighters could have done about it."
Principal Rondall Sanders arrived at the school early the next morning, when the building was still wreathed in smoke. As soon as it was safe, he toured what was left of his school. "When they finally let me in, everything was wet, muddy, and cold," he recalls as he walks through the main school building months later.
Here and there, scars remain. The tile floors are charred in the hallway where the arsonists piled up winter coats and set them ablaze. Burnt wiring still dangles from the ceiling. Some of the steel beams supporting the roof are noticeably twisted. In a room near the superintendent's office, an old safe sits in the center of the floor, soot-covered.
"This was the worst," Sanders says upon entering Charlene Fleming's chemistry classroom. "The sad part is, Mrs. Fleming took it personally. I've never seen such a hurt person. She felt like the kids must have been mad at her for something. But I don't think they had a thing in mind against her. Her door was unlocked. It was just a coincidence."
When Sanders later led students through the burned-out building, they were stunned when they reached Fleming's room. "When they got to this door," he says, "Mrs. Fleming was standing in the room. It was totally quiet. There was lots of emotion."
Fleming, a soft-spoken 23-year veteran of the Cross Plains schools, keeps a packet of photos of the school and her classroom she snapped the afternoon after the fire. "It was cold and dark and wet, and there was no electricity," she says. "It was almost like walking into a tomb."
She was relieved to learn that her room likely was not chosen out of spite. Some of what burned, though, were keepsakes from her many years in the classroom. "There was a teacher's prayer and a coffee cup students had given me," she says. Teaching in a different room, without these little mementos, has been disconcerting. "You just need to have something that's yours."
Joe Coppinger's English classroom was next door. It, too, sustained serious damage. "It was my 17th year in that room," he says. "And it was well-known that you don't mess with Mr. C's room. I had a real attachment to it."
Despite the fire, not a day of class was missed. Home economics classes were transplanted to a hallway of the elementary school. Students had history lessons in locker rooms. Math was taught in the old field house. Fleming took over a classroom in the nearby agricultural education building. And Sanders wedged his lanky body into a makeshift office in a storage room under the gymnasium bleachers.
The Abilene school district donated a three-room portable building, and many surrounding districts provided desks and supplies. Local businesses, like the Wal-Marts in Abilene and Brownwood, chipped in, too. There were no lockers, so students were given backpacks.
Sanders and his colleagues resolved to get back to business as soon as possible. But first they needed to attend to their own grief and to that of the students. On the Monday after the fire, Sanders convened a student assembly. "It was mainly to let students know what was going on," he says. "We asked people to just come up and talk. Some students wrote letters to the firefighters, thanking them for their help."
By that time, no arrests had been made, and most of the students were unaware that the two people responsible for the destruction sat in their midst.
Sanders knew, though. "Some of the kids had been telling us that there were some who left that party," he says. "I knew they were suspects." He recalls seeing the two boys at the assembly. "They were sitting about five rows behind me. They were having a tough time of it. They were sweating it out pretty bad."
In the fire's aftermath, local and state investigators gathered with officials from the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms. They, too, had heard about the party. Chief Duncan, together with an ATF officer, began nosing around. "We talked to the boys and interviewed a lot of kids at the party," Duncan says. "We thought these boys were lying to us. After we confronted them, they admitted it." By mid-afternoon on Monday, Dec. 8, both boys were under arrest.
Stories soon circulated about why the school was targeted. Local newspaper accounts suggested that the boys had burglarized the school's vending machines to take goodies back to the keg party and that the fires were set simply to cover their tracks.
Some people in town hinted that the boys had it in for the principal and the superintendent. Callahan County District Attorney Allen Wright, who prosecuted the two boys, says he heard rumors that at least one of the boys had a beef with a teacher or administrator and talked of setting fire to the school days earlier.
But Wright doesn't think the evidence suggests that. The offices of the principal and the superintendent were torched, but so were many other areas of the building. The boys have never explained why they set the fires, according to Wright. "I just think it was a prank," he says. "They went in there to do some vandalism, and apparently one thing led to another, and it got worse and worse."
Principal Sanders suggests the fire was the result of some partying that got out of hand. Neither boy had a record as a troublemaker before the fire.
|Some people in Cross Plains are ready to forgive the boys, but others doubt the two have undergone a conversion. They'll have to see it to believe it.|
One of the boys has returned to the school to talk about the dangers of substance abuse, and his family has spoken at drug-awareness events. According to his father, the boy had begun running with a fast crowd and was drunk the night of the fire. "From talking to our son, we just think it was something that got out of hand," the father says. "But it's not like we have all the answers at this point."
The father says the boy has undergone extensive psychological tests since his arrest, none of which indicates that he has deep-seated emotional problems. "This was an aberration," the father says, "We're thankful for that."
Joe Coppinger, who retired as a teacher at the end of last year to devote himself to his duties as pastor of the Cottonwood Baptist Church, knew the boy well. The boy's family, whose ancestors helped settle the area, is stable and supportive, Coppinger says. The father is a leader in the Cottonwood church. The boy is simply a good, smart kid who made an awful, stupid choice, Coppinger says. "He had no idea why he did it."
The other teenager did not have such a Norman Rockwell-like upbringing. He came from a broken family and was living with an older cousin before the fire, Wright says. The cousin indirectly played a role in the fire: He bought the beer for the keg party at the ranch, Wright says, and has since been convicted of serving alcohol to minors.
Although the boy was a starting lineman for the Buffaloes and got lots of help from people in town, he showed signs that he was troubled. "He grew up deprived of love and understanding," Coppinger says. "In the classroom, he liked to get lots of attention. He caused minor problems."
Whatever the boy's problems, Wright says, he was not a menace. The prosecutor has talked several times with the boy and his cousin. "They are nice boys, soft-spoken, polite. I don't know why they twisted off like this. These are not low-down, mean kids from a gang or something."
Coppinger, a tall, balding, and quietly authoritative man who speaks with a soft drawl, has ministered to the two teenagers since their arrest. They both regret what they did, he says, and the boy from his congregation is deepening his religious faith. "He's so repentant. He poured his heart out to me and told me how sorry he was."
Now, the boy reads the Bible every day and helps other teens learn their math at the Brownwood State School, run by the Texas Youth Commission. He hopes to go on to college and a career in the ministry, Coppinger says. "He wanted to go to TYC. He wanted a visible demonstration that he had paid the price. When he writes his letters from TYC, he sounds just like the apostle Paul."
The sign outside Jean's Feed Barn boasts "home cookin'" and advertises the day's special, catfish steak. Inside, the restaurant's vestibule is a shrine to the Cross Plains Buffaloes, its walls festooned with yellowing newspaper clippings. A computer-generated banner over the door to the dining room declares: "The Big Bad Buffs Are Here To Stay."
Proprietor Jean Wilson recalls hearing news of the two boys' arrests. Her diners, she says, "were in a state of shock. They couldn't believe that those types of people would do something like that. Everybody has really suffered from it, thinking of how uncalled-for it was."
At that point, she says, virtually no one was ready to forgive the boys. "It's a close-knit family," she says of Cross Plains. "When something like this happens, it's devastating to the whole community." But she says that, over time, feelings of anger and resentment faded, and the incident began to serve as a unifying force. "It has brought the whole community together to a certain extent," she says. "People here are so close. What hurts one hurts the whole community."
After the blaze, Charlene Fleming visited the home of one of the boys. She recalls finding "just a crushed little boy who knew he had done something terrible." She, too, hopes for the best, but she recognizes that some things can never be made right. "They might make it," she says. "They might make a difference in someone else's life. But they've lost a lot of their youth."
If there's anyone with a firm claim on hope, it's Joe Coppinger. As a minister, he believes the gospel leaves him little choice. And he's an ardent believer in an "all things are possible" philosophy; the words of the poet Alfred Lord Tennyson are enshrined on a plaque in his study: "More things are wrought by prayer than this world dreams of."
"This was such an awful thing they did," Coppinger concedes. But "if something good doesn't come out of it, it'll be even more terrible. I do believe something good is coming out of this, and it'll be worth more than a burned school."
Vol. 18, Issue 11, Pages 32-37Published in Print: November 11, 1998, as Fire Power