Q&A: Researcher Recounts a Short History of a Reform That Failed

January 15, 1992 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

Is a school reform successful or not? The answer sometimes depends on whom you ask, a recent article suggests.

Writing in the November 1991 issue of the Harvard Educational Review, Marjorie Godlin Roemer, the director of freshman English at the University of Cincinnati, recounts an attempt to develop a method of assessing writing through portfolios in the Cincinnati Public Schools. She considered the effort a failure, but teachers involved in the project saw it as a success.

The problem, she writes, was in the different perspectives of the school-system “insiders"--teachers and school administrators and “outsiders"--the university researchers. The insiders hoped that the experiment would result in concrete products--the new method of assessment. Since it did, the teachers and administrators regarded the experiment positively.

But the researchers intended the project to engage teachers in a discussion of their goals and expectations for students, a conversation that never occurred. As a result, Ms. Roemer writes, the portfolios fell short of their potential for empowering teachers. “A potentially liberating design was domesticated in a strictly hierarchical, utilitarian fashion,” she writes. “To the extent that much reform follows this pattern, it is often about change without difference.”

A better way of bringing teachers and university researchers together, Ms. Roemer suggests, is along the lines of the National Writing Project, which provides educators an opportunity--away from the daily pressures of the classroom--to reflect on their practice.

Ms. Roemer discussed her article, and its implications for school-university collaborations, with Associate Editor Robert Rothman.

Q. Why do you think the “insiders” and the “outsiders” had such divergent perspectives on the purposes and the outcomes of the project?

A. I think it was our position, our orientation.

I think public-school teachers are working under trying conditions, and they really don’t have the luxury to reflect, to experiment, to explore. They feel pressed .... The kind of conceptions some of us [university researchers] had wasn’t feasible. University researchers could afford the luxury of a reflective stance.

Another piece [of the difference] was the antagonism and suspicion that developed {over the course of the project]. There was a sense among high-school teachers that people can’t know what pressures they labor under.

Q. Isn’t it possible that you are selling the reform short, and that the project may be successful, over time, as the teachers implement the portfolios?

A. It’s possible. Some writing will get done, and some teachers said students really are taking writing seriously. There is some real change there.

I suppose that the project fell far short of my desires for it. I would have liked the process itself to create something empowering for the teachers. I would have liked it to be their project, in a richer way than it was.

But something in the experience drained what meaning there could be. That’s irrecoverable.

Q. Would the divergence in perspectives be true in any collaboration, or can you see ways of bringing the two groups together?

A. I ended by feeling that, for me, it would be more satisfying to work with the National Writing Project model .... That calls for a break in the routine, to build a new community to reconceptualize [teaching].

There might be circumstances where one could overcome the inside-outside split. We didn’t give enough thought to what the problems might be, and ways around them.

It would take more time, more money, and more trust in teachers.

Q. In the examples of successful collaboration you cite, you write that there is time for “thoughtful consideration of practice.” In those instances, is there evidence that the reforms are implemented in a way that produces “real change?”

A. I think so. You have to change the way teachers think. That’s what didn’t happen {in the Cincinnati experiment]. They got a process to monitor student performance. We didn’t see changed consciousness.

Q. There is a trend now of teachers’ conducting their own research. Does that help merge the differences between the insiders’ and outsiders’ perspectives, or do such efforts rob experiments of the perspective a university researcher might provide?

A. I’d like to think there is a place for university-school collaboration. But I am very much in support of the teacher-as researcher movement.

I want university people helping, not being the experts, the repositories of knowledge. That was my frustration. That was the way we were perceived, whether we liked it or not.

A version of this article appeared in the January 15, 1992 edition of Education Week as Q&A: Researcher Recounts a Short History of a Reform That Failed


English-Language Learners Webinar Helping English-Learners Through Improved Parent Outreach: Strategies That Work
Communicating with families is key to helping students thrive – and that’s become even more apparent during a pandemic that’s upended student well-being and forced constant logistical changes in schools. Educators should pay particular attention
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Mathematics Webinar
Addressing Unfinished Learning in Math: Providing Tutoring at Scale
Most states as well as the federal government have landed on tutoring as a key strategy to address unfinished learning from the pandemic. Take math, for example. Studies have found that students lost more ground
Content provided by Yup Math Tutoring
Classroom Technology Webinar Building Better Blended Learning in K-12 Schools
The pandemic and the increasing use of technology in K-12 education it prompted has added renewed energy to the blended learning movement as most students are now learning in school buildings (and will likely continue

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

Education Nearly a Million Kids Vaccinated in Week 1, White House Says
Experts say there are signs that it will be difficult to sustain the initial momentum.
4 min read
Leo Hahn, 11, gets the first shot of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine, Tuesday, Nov. 9, 2021, at the University of Washington Medical Center in Seattle. Last week, U.S. health officials gave the final signoff to Pfizer's kid-size COVID-19 shot, a milestone that opened a major expansion of the nation's vaccination campaign to children as young as 5. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Education How Schools Are Getting Kids the COVID Shot, and Why Some Aren’t
Some district leaders say offering vaccine clinics, with the involvement of trusted school staff, is key to helping overcome hesitancy.
5 min read
A girl walks outside of a mobile vaccine unit after getting the first dose of her COVID-19 vaccine, outside P.S. 277, Friday, Nov. 5, 2021, in the Bronx borough of New York. (AP Photo/Eduardo Munoz Alvarez)
Education Biden Administration Urges Schools to Provide COVID-19 Shots, Information for Kids
The Biden administration is encouraging local school districts to host vaccine clinics for kids and information on benefits of the shots.
2 min read
President Joe Biden, and first lady Jill Biden walk to board Marine One on the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, Saturday, Nov. 6, 2021. Biden is spending the weekend at his home in Rehoboth Beach, Del. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)
Education Civil Rights Groups Sue Tennessee Over Law Against Transgender Student Athletes
The state law bars transgender athletes from playing public high school or middle school sports aligned with their gender identity.
3 min read
Amy Allen, the mother of an 8th grade transgender son, speaks after a Human Rights Campaign round table discussion on anti-transgender laws in Nashville, Tenn. on May 21, 2021.
Amy Allen, the mother of an 8th grade transgender son, speaks after a Human Rights Campaign round table discussion on anti-transgender laws in Nashville, Tenn. on May 21, 2021.
Mark Humphrey/AP