Fewer Latino Students Select Four-Year Colleges
By attending Oregon State University rather than a community college, 21-year-old Doris Gonzalez Gomez has taken a step out of the norm for many Latinos to boost her prospects to earn a bachelor’s degree.
When Latinos go to college, they are less likely than any other major racial or ethnic group to attend a four-year college or university, according to an unpublished analysis of federal education data by the Pew Hispanic Center. That’s a concern to educators because students who start at community colleges are less likely than their peers beginning postsecondary studies at four-year institutions to earn bachelor’s degrees, which statistics show typically translate into better pay in the labor market.
Ms. Gonzalez is an intern this summer for U.S. Congresswoman Judy Chu, a Democrat from California. She’s among 30 Latinos selected by the Washington-based Congressional Hispanic Caucus Institute to be interns on Capitol Hill this summer. All but one of the interns are attending four-year colleges.
Ms. Gonzalez is the U.S.-born daughter of Mexican immigrants who worked as migrant pickers of apples, pears, and apricots when she was a child. Now, her father, who finished 3rd grade in Mexico, is a maintenance worker for a golf course. Her mother, who completed 6th grade, is a janitor for an elementary school.
“I always knew a lot of people expect us [Latinos] to go to a community college,” Ms. Gonzalez said in an interview recently. “I wanted a full experience of going to a four-year college.”
Ms. Gonzalez says a recruiter for a federal program for migrant students, the College Assistance Migrant Program, guided her while in high school to apply to and get accepted by a four-year university.
Five congressional interns interviewed for this article, all of whom are from low-income families and are the first in their families to attend a four-year institution of higher education, credited different factors with helping them to look beyond attending a community college.
One of the five said the assistance of a high school guidance counselor was crucial. The rest got advice elsewhere, such as from peers in Advanced Placement or honors courses.
But they are a minority among their peers. Nationwide, 48 percent of Latinos who are first-time, full-time college freshmen enroll in four-year institutions. That’s the lowest proportion of any major racial or ethnic group, Richard Fry, a senior research associate for the Washington-based Pew Hispanic Center, found in an analysis of 2008 data from the federally administered Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System. Meanwhile, the proportion of students enrolling in four-year institutions is 69 percent for Asian or Pacific Islander students, 66 percent for whites, 54 percent for blacks, and 53 percent for American Indians or Alaska Natives.
The problem with Latinos gravitating toward community colleges, said Mr. Fry, is that “on average, if a student wants to complete a bachelor’s degree, they are more likely to succeed if they start at a four-year school.” He added, “The plum in higher education, in terms of the labor market, is for students to get four-year bachelor’s degrees.”
Mr. Fry said that not only does it matter for students’ economic prospects that they attend four-year institutions of higher education, but it also matters which four-year schools they attend. “Even when Hispanics go to four-year schools, they tend to go to the less academically selective ones,” he said. That’s a problem because the more selective colleges are, the better they tend to be in getting their freshmen to earn bachelor’s degrees, he said.
Part of the difficulty for Latinos may be finances. Overall, the proportion of college-eligible, low-income students across the nation who are going to four-year colleges or universities is declining, according to a federal report sent to the U.S. Congress and the U.S. Department of Education last month by the Advisory Committee on Student Financial Assistance, which gives Congress advice on student financial aid policy. And a large number of Latino students live in low-income households. The U.S. Bureau of the Census reports that in 2008, 23.2 percent of Latinos lived in poverty.
That report said enrollment in four-year colleges was 40 percent in 2004 for students from low-income families who had taken mathematics classes at least at the level of Algebra II in high school, down from 54 percent in 1992.
Mr. Fry said Latinos tend to go to community colleges, in part, because they are concentrated in states—including California, Florida, New York, and Texas—that have well-developed community-college systems. Also, he said, Latinos on average are less academically prepared than students from some other racial and ethnic groups, prompting many students to pick community colleges for their less-selective admissions processes.
In addition, the Latino interns interviewed for this article gave mixed reports on the helpfulness of their guidance counselors.
Ms. Gonzalez had a bad experience with a guidance counselor as a high school freshman. “‘I see something wrong with your schedule. I’m concerned you have five Advanced Placement courses,’” Ms. Gonzalez recalled the counselor telling her. She said the counselor asked her to sign up for regular classes instead. But Ms. Gonzalez, accompanied by her parents, approached a second guidance counselor at her high school, and that counselor let Ms. Gonzalez enroll in the AP classes. “I would say my guidance counselors didn’t help me, but I did have other teachers who supported me in my dream of going to college,” Ms. Gonzalez said.
And it was a recruiter for the federal College Assistance Migrant Program, Ms. Gonzalez said, who told her how to land scholarship money, apply for financial aid, and find housing so that she could go to Oregon State. It’s the only college to which Ms. Gonzalez applied. She is a senior majoring in philosophy.
By contrast, without the help of his high school guidance counselor, Jefrey Velasquez, 20, who is an intern for U.S. Rep. José E. Serrano, of New York, this summer, said he likely would have attended a community college. Instead he chose Mount St. Mary College, in Newburgh, N.Y., where he is a junior majoring in history.
The son of immigrants from Honduras, Velasquez was born and raised in the Bronx borough of New York City by a single mom who works as a home attendant for the elderly. His mother attended high school in Honduras but never went to college. Mr. Velasquez didn’t know English until he went to school.
He said he and his high school guidance counselor, an African-American born in the Bronx, “kind of clicked.” While Mr. Velasquez didn’t think he could afford to attend a four-year school, his guidance counselor convinced him otherwise. He helped Mr. Velasquez get a scholarship and land a post as a resident assistant.
A report released by Public Agenda this past spring, titled “Can I Get a Little Advice Here?” depicts the high school guidance system as “overstretched.” On average, the report said, one guidance counselor serves 460 students.
Public Agenda, a nonprofit research organization in New York City, concluded based on its survey of 600 young adults that “the judgments young people make about their high school counselors are often harsh, considerably harsher than the judgments they make about their high school teachers or their advisers at the postsecondary level.”
Access to good advice on going to college also may be particularly crucial for students from low-income or minority families because, unlike students from many middle-class families, they may not be able to ask parents to fill in that counseling gap. Many such students come from families in which neither parent attended college.
The knowledge that college guidance may be lacking for many students has led some researchers to look into what approaches can effectively supplement the support that guidance counselors provide to students.
Researchers at the Oakland, Calif.-based Berkeley Policy Associates, for example, were commissioned by the Education Department’s Institute of Education Sciences to determine what it might take to get students into four-year state schools in California—particularly students who had the academic preparation to be admitted but lacked information about the application process. The study connected high school students attending Los Angeles Unified School District with college mentors. The mentors assisted the students, starting at the end of their junior year, with steps such as writing and revising an essay and applying for federal financial aid for admission to universities in the California State or University of California systems.
The study found that before the intervention was launched, 50 percent of the students in Los Angeles Unified Schools who were qualified to attend the four-year state schools weren’t going, according to Jacqueline Berman, who was the project director for the study, which began in 2006. “These kids don’t need remedial math and reading. They just need to know how to get into college and how to afford it,” she said.
Ms. Berman said that fewer than a third of African-American and Latino students from L.A. Unified who were eligible to be admitted to the California four-year universities ended up there.
Of 2,500 students identified as being eligible for admission to the state schools, 1,000 were assigned to mentors and 1,500 were not. The researchers tried to assign paid mentors, who were either undergraduate or graduate students from nearby colleges, to high schoolers with whom they shared a similar background, such as coming from a Spanish-speaking home. The intervention cost about $1,000 per student.
The researchers concluded that the strategy was effective in increasing the number of students going to California State or University of California universities.
“The good news is it’s a relatively small gap to bridge. We had higher impacts for kids who were Spanish-speaking and whose parents didn’t go to college,” Ms. Berman said.
She said that the study indicates that a low-cost intervention provided over a rather short period of time can increase the proportion of students who attend four-year colleges or universities.
Vol. 29, Issue 37
Get more stories and free e-newsletters!
- Superintendent, Cedar Rapids Community School District
- Cedar Rapids Community School District, Cedar Rapids, IA
- Founding Principal, Charter School
- OLD STURBRIDGE VILLAGE, INC., Sturbridge, MA
- Vice President, Teacher Preparation Strategies
- National Council on Teacher Quality, Washington, DC
- Faculty, pre-school, international school
- Scholastica, Dhaka, Dh, Bangladesh
- Roaring Fork School DIstrict, Carbondale, CO