Afghan Education Shows Progress Amid the Rubble
Afghanistan suffered another blow to its campaign to rebuild its ravaged school system last week when a rocket exploded on the grounds of a school in Asadabad, killing six children. But the spate of recent attacks on schools, teachers, and students has not threatened plans to open up educational opportunities for all children, especially girls, throughout the Southern Asian nation, observers say.
U.S. agencies, private donors, and international aid organizations have reported marked headway in building new schools, recruiting and training teachers, and providing basic instructional materials. And demand for education throughout much of the country has exceeded expectations.
“More than 4.3 million children are enrolled in schools; about 40 percent of those are girls,” said Hassan Mohamed, a senior technical adviser on education for CARE, a humanitarian organization. “That is significant progress since when the Taliban was in power, and in the history of the whole country, … we have never achieved such progress before.”
Such progress was among the goals for rebuilding Afghanistan in the months after the United States and its allies began military operations to topple the extremist Taliban government and weed out terrorists in October 2001. Building schools and expanding educational opportunities for boys and girls, officials and aid workers said, would help foster democracy in a nation where basic rights, especially for girls and women, had long been suppressed.
Now, as Education Minister Noor Mohammad Qarqeen kicked off the start of a new school year last month, he announced plans to build 1,000 new schools, according to the Pajhwok Afghan News, a national news service in the country. CARE officials said they would be working with the U.S. Agency for International Development, an independent federal agency that assists foreign nations, to open additional schools in rural areas over the next five years.
Security Biggest Issue
USAID has helped build nearly 500 schools, train some 11,000 teachers, and print and distribute 48 million textbooks in Pashto and Dari, according to the agency’s report on education issued in January.
Other aid organizations, such as UNICEF and the World Bank, have also reported progress in opening new schools.
“Today is another step toward the reconstruction of Afghanistan, toward a country that puts women and children first,” UNICEF Deputy Executive Director Rima Salah said at an education rally last month. The event, attended by dozens of residents in the region—the site of ancient stone carvings of Buddha that were destroyed by the Taliban—was broadcast on the organization’s Web site.
“There is a minority here that does not value education as much as you do,” Ms. Salah said, “but I’m sure you can be an example to them. They will not succeed in holding you back.”
But making education accessible and safe for all school-age children has proved challenging in a country still struggling to overcome poverty, sectarian and tribal strife, and the climate of fear fostered by the Taliban regime.
“The security issue is still the biggest issue in Afghanistan,” said Barry Rosen, the director of a curriculum and teacher-training project in Kabul sponsored by Teachers College, Columbia University. “Until and unless that situation is changed, it will be very hard to not just build schools but to also build the educational system to where teachers are actually teaching.”
About a dozen schools have been bombed, burned, or otherwise vandalized since last fall. The wave of attacks included one by suspected Taliban insurgents in which a teacher was beheaded in front of his family, reportedly for teaching girls.
Insurgents have also sent threatening letters to parents in some regions—primarily rural areas—warning that their children, especially girls, are in danger if they attend school.
Those threats and incidents have not dampened Afghanis’ enthusiasm for education, according to Mr. Mohamed of CARE.
“Even during the height of the Taliban regime, when the Taliban was against girls’ education, communities were willing to risk to send their girls to home schools and underground schools,” he said from his organization’s offices in Washington. “The violence doesn’t have a large-scale effect; it is mostly localized.”
More than 1 million school-age Afghan girls are not participating in education, according to UNICEF estimates. Thousands of students in rural areas attend school in tents or other rudimentary structures, according to news reports. And teachers have walked in some provinces to protest delays in getting paid.
Teachers College, meanwhile, has suspended its project in Afghanistan after a U.S.-financed program to draft curricula was halted because of debates over the content, Mr. Rosen said. The project had already produced and distributed curriculum and textbooks for 1st graders in mathematics, science, social studies, and the Dari and Pashto languages. Teachers College had also trained several hundred teachers in using the materials.
But while access to schooling has been growing, the quality of the facilities, teachers, and instructional programs are widely questioned. Classrooms are often crowded, teachers are poorly paid, and many have not had enough education themselves, Mr. Rosen said.
“The students are learning basic skills,” he said, “but how well and in what ways is another thing.”
Vol. 25, Issue 32, Page 10Published in Print: April 19, 2006, as Afghan Education Shows Progress Amid the Rubble