Audit Questions Oversight of Ill. Education Agency
A state audit has raised serious questions about accountability and oversight at the Illinois education department and about Superintendent Joseph A. Spagnolo's stewardship.
The voluminous report, released March 12 by William Holland, the auditor general, describes a "breakdown in the fundamental principle of administration" of the agency's $23 million operational budget. It cites 45 examples of what the auditors see as mismanagement and other errors, including inadequate oversight of federal grant programs, personnel, and contracts.
The audit, which covered the two years that ended June 30, 1996, also cites "deficiencies in control" over Mr. Spagnolo's travel, headquarters, and other expenses.
The report comes at a critical time for Republican Gov. Jim Edgar and Illinois lawmakers, who seem poised to revamp the state's school funding formula after years of political wrangling. Schools in the state receive most of their money from local property taxes, and wide spending disparities exist between property-rich and poor school districts. ("Odds Seen Better for Funding Reform in Ill.," Feb. 5, 1997.)
The state audit, said Larry McNeal, an associate professor of school finance at Illinois State University in Normal, could erode support for reform efforts.
"It's diverting attention from the vital issue of providing resources and a quality education to kids," he said. "Critics will use this to say, 'If there's that much money to mismanage, there's too much money in the first place.'"
Gov. Edgar, who has been traveling the state to trumpet his ideas for raising income taxes, lowering property taxes, and changing the school distribution formula, said a review of the audit found "no smoking guns." But some legislators disagreed.
"It's the worst audit I have ever seen in my 20-some years around here," Senate President James "Pate" Philip, a Republican, told the Copley News Service the day after the report was released. "It was very poor management. ... I've never seen [an audit] that bad, ever."
Another leading gop lawmaker, Dan Cronin, the chairman of the Senate education committee, told the news service that Mr. Spagnolo's hold on the appointive position may not be secure.
"It's fair to say that, while I like [Joe Spagnolo] personally, there are some serious questions that have to be answered," he said.
No Plans To Leave
In an interview last week, Mr. Spagnolo conceded that "mistakes were made" and that "record keeping was not as detailed as it should have been" at the agency. But he said he had no plans to leave office.
"There was never a doubt about my staying. The board is supportive; the governor is supportive," he said. "We've taken some positive steps to address the problems and are anxious to get on with the business at hand."
The state board appointed Mr. Spagnolo in June of 1994. His contract expires in 1999.
The schools chief has been under fire since last fall, when questions first surfaced about several highly paid consultants to the agency, dozens of no-bid contracts, and excessive expenses for business travel.
In December, a new law pared the state board of education from 17 members to nine and authorized Gov. Edgar to appoint members and name the board's chairman.
At the time, several lawmakers asked the governor to appoint a board that would oust Mr. Spagnolo. But the governor praised the superintendent's education initiatives and supported his continued tenure.
In January, the Senate confirmed five of the governor's new appointees, including board Chairman Louis Mervis. But it delayed confirming four returning board members until the state audit was released.
On March 17, the senate voted 56-2 to confirm the returning board members, and the new board met for the first time last week.
Kim Kanauer, a spokeswoman for the board said the audit has provided the new board and the superintendent with an opportunity to develop a systematic oversight plan that will better detail the use of the agency's funds.
The plan, released this month in response to the audit, includes monthly board meetings to review expenses, the retraining of the agency's 700-plus staff members on bookkeeping protocol, and the appointment of a "second in command" to Mr. Spagnolo who will work to improve management of the agency and of the superintendent's office.
In the coming months, a liaison from the U.S. Department of Education will help the board revise its record keeping for $24 million in federal grants.