English-Language Learners

Bilingual Educators Challenge E.D.'s ‘English Only’ Proposal

By James Crawford — April 15, 1987 5 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print

For most bilingual educators, it was the first chance to challenge an official of the U.S. Education Department on its campaign to expand federal funding for “English only’’ teaching methodologies.

For Carol Pendas Whitten, director of the office of bilingual education and minority languages affairs, it was a heated policy debate that turned personal.

The confrontation, which had been brewing for the past 18 months, erupted here earlier this month, at the 16th annual convention of the National Association for Bilingual Education.

After addressing the group, Ms. Whitten stormed out of a question-and-answer session in which speakers voiced near-unanimous disapproval of the department’s policies on bilingual education.

“I thought I was addressing a professional organization, instead of a political-action committee,’' Ms. Whitten said, visibly angered as she left the podium shortly before the session was scheduled to end.

In her speech, Ms. Whitten maintained that, “despite allegations to the contrary,’' the department’s intention is not to mount an “attack on bilingual education ... [or] to promote one method of instruction over another.’'

Rather, she said, its goal is “increased flexibility’’ for local school districts to decide what method is best for instructing limited-English-proficient children.

“We should recognize that there is no one best method of instruction, for all children, under all circumstances,’' she said.

But members of the audience rose to rebut Ms. Whitten’s assertions. “Local control sounds like basic democracy,’' said Bob Peterson, a 5th-grade bilingual teacher from Milwaukee, “but [sometimes] local control has meant the perpetuation of a racist and segregationist system.’'

“This is why people in the civil-rights movement and people who support bilingual education have had to force the federal government to issue regulations to ensure that minority populations have their rights guaranteed,’' he said.

Immersion Debate

Other speakers disputed Ms. Whitten’s position that English-only programs, such as “structured immersion,’' can be at least as effective as bilingual instruction. Angel Gonzales, an administrator in the Houston Independent School District, said experimental English-immersion programs in his district “just produce English-speaking illiterates.’'

“A majority of the [immersion] youngsters have been retained for two or more years,’' he added, “and the bilingual children are scoring better in the 4th and 5th grades on English tests. But the biggest problem is that most of [the immersion students] are exiting to special education.’'

Ms. Whitten and other OBEMLA officials who promote immersion “are not educators,’' Mr. Gonzalez said in an interview. “All they care about is that the children learn English. They don’t understand there’s a difference between learning a language and learning. These are two different issues.’'

English-immersion projects in eight Texas districts, including Houston, were launched in 1981 by the Texas Education Agency as an experiment in alternatives to bilingual education. But the project will be terminated this spring, according to Ramon Magallanes of the agency’s special-programs office.

The state’s commissioner of education, William Kirby, recently informed participating districts that they must now comply with a state law requiring bilingual classrooms in schools that enroll 20 or more LEP children from the same language group.

Preliminary reports indicate that some “recent-arrival students,’' who had well-developed skills in their native languages, benefited from the English-only approaches at the high-school level, Mr. Magallanes said.

But the alternative programs appeared to be a failure for elementary students, he reported, according to test results from several districts.

In Houston, for example, the English-immersion children who scored highest were often among the 60 percent who had been retained in grade. Mr. Magallanes added that some districts dropped out of the pilot project after they saw how poorly students were faring.

Ms. Whitten said more conclusive evidence about immersion will be available in two years, following the completion of a federally financed longitudinal study comparing immersion with bilingual instruction.

The study’s first-year scores, leaked to the press last year, indicated that children in bilingual programs were significantly outperforming immersion students on achievement tests in English. (See Education Week, April 23, 1986.)

Alan Ginsburg, an official in the department’s office of planning, budget, and evaluation, said the second-year test data would be released within the next two weeks.

Rancorous Relations

Ms. Whitten’s assurances that the department would continue to support bilingual education--even if the Congress removes funding restrictions for English-only programs--were challenged by several members of the bilingual-educators’ association.

Luis Reyes, executive director of Aspira of New York, a Puerto Rican advocacy group, took issue with the suggestion by Secretary of Education William J. Bennett that bilingual education is to blame for high dropout rates among Hispanic youths.

In New York City, Mr. Reyes said, only one Latino student in four is eligible for bilingual education, and of those, only 37 percent are served. For the 12 percent of Hispanic children receiving it, he argued, “bilingual education is a dropout-prevention strategy.’'

Alma Flor Aba, a professor of education at the University of San Francisco, accused Ms. Whitten of “not taking a stand’’ against opponents of bilingual education within the Reagan Administration.

In Spanish, Ms. Aba quoted the Cuban patriot Jose Marti’s condemnation of “the crime of silence.’'

Ms. Whitten, a Cuban-American, at first appeared at a loss for words, then voiced her criticism of the organization and walked out of the auditorium.

Several members of the group said relations between the bilingual-educators’ association and OBEMLA could hardly deteriorate further. They noted that, beginning this year, Ms. Whitten had changed administrative regulations to prohibit the use of bilingual-education grants to travel to conferences and training sessions not sponsored by the Education Department.

The decision appeared to reduce attendance at the association’s conference this year, which registered 1,600 participants, compared with about 2,000 at its meeting last year in Chicago.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the April 15, 1987 edition of Education Week as Bilingual Educators Challenge E.D.'s ‘English Only’ Proposal

Events

Ed-Tech Policy Webinar Artificial Intelligence in Practice: Building a Roadmap for AI Use in Schools
AI in education: game-changer or classroom chaos? Join our webinar & learn how to navigate this evolving tech responsibly.
Education Webinar Developing and Executing Impactful Research Campaigns to Fuel Your Ed Marketing Strategy 
Develop impactful research campaigns to fuel your marketing. Join the EdWeek Research Center for a webinar with actionable take-aways for companies who sell to K-12 districts.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Privacy & Security Webinar
Navigating Cybersecurity: Securing District Documents and Data
Learn how K-12 districts are addressing the challenges of maintaining a secure tech environment, managing documents and data, automating critical processes, and doing it all with limited resources.
Content provided by Softdocs

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
View Jobs
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
View Jobs
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
View Jobs
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.
View Jobs

Read Next

English-Language Learners Nuanced Accountability Would Help English Learners. New Research Shows How
A new report offers suggestions on how states can approach federal accountability measures with more nuance for English learners.
5 min read
The child is studying the alphabet.
Germanovich/iStock/Getty
English-Language Learners Opinion How to Connect With English-Language Newcomers. Teachers Share Their Favorite Lessons
Stock classrooms with books that reflect students’ lives, languages, and cultures and invite them into as yet unfamiliar worlds.
10 min read
Images shows colorful speech bubbles that say "Q," "&," and "A."
iStock/Getty
English-Language Learners Do Immigrant Students Help the Academic Outcomes of U.S.-Born Peers? One Study Says Yes
Schools and districts across the country have recently been reporting larger numbers of immigrant student enrollment, researchers say.
5 min read
Eric Parker teaches a class NW Classen High that has immigrant students and he has a flag representing each, which is a way to make them feel welcome, Tuesday, September 10, 2019.
Eric Parker teaches a class NW Classen High that has immigrant students and he has a flag representing each, which is a way to make them feel welcome, Tuesday, September 10, 2019. In a study published in the Review of Economic Studies last year, researchers analyzed population-level school records and birth records from Florida to measure the impact of immigrant students on U.S.-born peers’ academic outcomes.
Doug Hoke/The Oklahoman via AP
English-Language Learners Federal Funding for English Learners Has a New Home. What Do Educators Hope This Means?
$890 million in Title III grants moved to the federal office of English language acquisition in December.
4 min read
Billy Lopez and Indica Beckham read together during kindergarten class at Fairview Elementary in Carthage, Mo., on Nov. 26, 2018. The Carthage School District, along with three other Missouri districts, is participating in a $2.6 million five-year grant project that seeks to bolster its English Language Learners program. The grant will provide ELL training to teachers in the Carthage, Kansas City Public, Bayless and Columbia school districts.
Billy Lopez and Indica Beckham read together during kindergarten class at Fairview Elementary in Carthage, Mo., on Nov. 26, 2018. The Carthage School District, along with three other Missouri districts, is participating in a $2.6 million five-year grant project that seeks to bolster its English Language Learners program.
Roger Nomer/The Joplin Globe via AP